39. You observe how
much difference he makes between the souls of men and the angels.
Merely the difference between the
one sheep and the others,
between one drachma and the rest. But he adds something more, a little
way further; he says:
“As to what the Apostle
says, “That he might create in himself of two one new man, so
making peace,” though it seems to be even more applicable than
the former passage to the case of Jews and Gentiles, it may be adapted
to our understanding of the passage in this way: We may suppose him to
mean that man, who was made after the image and similitude of God, is
after his reconciliation to receive the same form which the angels now
have and he has lost: and he calls him a new man because he is renewed
day by day, and is to dwell in the new world.”
The souls of men then, differ,
according to him, from the angels as sheep from sheep or as drachma
from drachma; and men will have that form hereafter which the angels
now have, but which men once had and had lost. If then there is no
difference between them in nature, in shape or in form, I wonder that
our learned man is not ashamed to condemn another person for saying
what he himself has said, and especially when you observe that this is
an exposition not of the Vulgate rendering but of the real meaning of
the Apostle. But see what is added further in the same place. He
presently says:
“And the creation of the
new man will be fully and completely perfected when things in heaven
and things in earth shall be joined in one, and we have access to the
Father in one spirit, in one feeling and mind. There is something
similar suggested by Paul to all thoughtful readers in another Epistle
(though some do not receive it as his), in these words:
2901
“All these, having had witness borne
of their faith, received not the promise, God having provided some
better thing for us, that apart from us they should not be made
perfect.” For this reason the whole creation
2902
groans and travails with pain in sympathy
with us who groan in this tabernacle, who have conceived in the womb by
the fear of God,
2903
and are in grief
and wait for the revelation of the sons of God; and it waits to be
delivered from the vanity of the bondage to which it is now subject; so
that there may be one shepherd and one flock, and that the petition in
the Lord’s Prayer may be fulfilled, “Thy will be done in
earth as it is in heaven.””
We are to understand then that
things in heaven and those on earth, that is, Angels and men, formerly
had one form and one sheepfold, and that so it will be in their future
restoration, since Christ will come to make both into one flock, and
men are to be what angels now are, and what they, that is their souls,
previously were. I ask then, with what face you can mock, as we lately
saw you, so pleasantly, or rather not pleasantly at all but
scurrilously, at those poor women who, striking their bellies and
thighs, said that they should not after the resurrection have those
frail bodies but would be like the angels and have a life like theirs.
You reprove with bitter raillery these poor women for saying the very
things which are now produced as passages from these selected
Commentaries of yours. Do not you think this is somewhat as if a man
were to accuse another of theft, while he had the very thing that had
been stolen concealed in the bosom of his toga; and as if, after
inveighing against the supposed thief in a long and magnificent
peroration, after bringing forward witnesses and taking the oath in due
form, he should have the stolen article extracted from his toga which
he supposed himself to have convicted another of stealing.
There is another point. You find
fault with others because, when questions are asked them about such
matters, they do not answer at once, but hesitate and use gestures
rather than words. Yet you say that the Apostle does much the same, at
least, that he ‘insinuates’ something of this kind in his
Epistle to thoughtful men. If Paul does not plainly declare these
things, but ‘insinuates’ them, and this not to everybody
but only to thoughtful people, why do you, whom we are bringing to see
your errors, laugh at us poor creatures when we say about things which
the Apostle has not plainly declared either that we do not know, or
that we stand in doubt, and that, since we do not get a full
understanding but a hint of his meaning, we do not declare but suggest
an explanation. If the things which eye hath not seen nor ear heard,
and which have not entered into the heart of man have been revealed to
you; if you have attained to that which is perfect, and that which is
in part is done away for you; shout aloud and proclaim the truth, and
make quite plain the things which you say the Apostle
‘insinuates,’ since not only what he insinuates but what he
asserts, as you tell us, now falls under your ban. All these things on
which you now desire us to pronounce anathema are those which you had
ascribed to the Apostle in your exposition of his words, and had taught
as contained in the scope of his statements.
2901
Heb. xi. 39,
40
2902
Rom. viii. 22
2903
Qui a timore Dei in utero concepimus.
The expression is meant to carry out the metaphor of the
word
συνωδινει
“travaileth together.”