Chapter
XIX
.—
The Episcopal Chair of
James.
The
chair of James, who first received the episcopate of the church at
Jerusalem from the Saviour himself
2300
and the
apostles, and who, as the divine records show,
2301
was called a brother of Christ, has been preserved until now,
2302
the brethren who have followed him in
succession there exhibiting clearly to all the reverence which both
those of old times and those of our own day maintained and do maintain
for holy men on account of their piety. So much as to this
matter.
2300
That
James was appointed bishop of Jerusalem by Christ himself was an old
and wide-spread tradition. Compare, e.g., the Clementine
Recognitions,
Bk. I. chap. 43, the
Apostolic
Constitutions,
Bk. VIII. chap. 35, and Chrysostom’s
Homily
XXXVII. on First Corinthians.
See Valesius’ note
ad
locum;
and on the universal tradition that James was bishop of
Jerusalem, see above, Bk. II. chap. 1, note 11.
2301
See
Gal. i. 19
. On the actual relationship of “James, the Brother of
the Lord” to Christ, see Bk. I. chap. 12, note 14.
2302
There can be no doubt that a chair (
θρόνος
),
said to be the episcopal seat of James, the first bishop of Jerusalem,
was shown in that church in the time of Eusebius, but there can be no
less doubt that it was not genuine. Even had James been bishop of
Jerusalem, and possessed a regular episcopal chair, or throne (a very
violent supposition, which involves a most glaring anachronism), it was
quite out of the question that it should have been preserved from
destruction at the fall of the city in 70
a.d.
As Stroth drily remarks: “Man hatte auch wohl nichts wichtigeres
zu retten, als einen Stuhl!” The beginning of that veneration of
relics which later took such strong hold on the Church, and which still
flourishes within the Greek and Roman communions is clearly seen in
this case recorded by Eusebius. At the same time, we can hardly say
that that superstitious veneration with which we are acquainted
appeared in this case. There seems to be nothing more than the
customary respect for an article of old and time-honored associations
which is seen everywhere and in all ages (cf. Heinichen’s
Excursus on this passage, Vol. III. p. 208 sq.). Crusè has
unaccountably rendered
θρόνος
in
this passage as if it referred to the see of Jerusalem, not to the
chair of the bishop. It is plain enough that such an interpretation is
quite unwarranted.