UNASKED AND PRAYER
James 4:2-3
2 Ye lust, and have not:---The word "lust," (epithumeite, present active indicative of epithumeo, from epi and thumos, to have a strong passion for), denotes the intensity of feeling characteristic of those to whom James wrote, and explains why "wars" and "fightings" alluded to in verse 1 often arose among them. Coveting what another has, whether on an individual, national or international level, is the basic cause of war, whether such warfare be literal or figurative; and Jam es thus traces to its source the evil which results from such unlawful desire. This lust for what one does not have has led to the gravest of crimes, examples of which may be seen in David, in the matter of Bathsheba (2 Samuel 11:1), and Ahab, in the matter of Naboth's vineyard (1 Kings 21:2-4). When desire of this character is entertained and encouraged, it becomes overpowering and the dominant feature in one's life. In such a case, desire is the master of the soul; and the individual thus possessed is enslaved and helplessly propelled to the very vortex of sin. Here, indeed. is the test by which all of us may easily and accurately determine the principle by which our lives are governed.
May we truly say, "Thy will be done;" or, "My desires be satisfied ?" It should be remembered that the rich man of Luke 16, was not charged with serious crimes against man or God; it is not affirmed of him that he engaged in bad things; he is said to have had hi:; good things here; yet, he was rejected because fleshly gratification and the love of things material were the dominant factors of his life. He who wottld gain heaven must sacrifice the things of the world. We must choose whether to have our good things here, or hereafter ; we cannot have them both here and hereafter!
These particularly in the mind of James when he wrote, despite their burning desire, did not obtain the things which they coveted. And why did they not? The answer is that they did not seek for the things for which they might properly ask God. Here, we meet with another vital test in the realm of religion. When (aced with the necessity of deciding whether any given act is open to participation for the faithful Christian, one need only ask, Will God approve? Seldom is it difficult to find the answer to this question.
And, where any doubt whatever exists, it is the part of prudence to refrain. The devoted disciple will not attempt to force the Scripture into support of his position; he will seek only to be sure that his position is on the side of Scripture! These of whom James wrote, notwithstanding their intense desires, and the efforts expended to realize them, were without that upon which they had set their hearts.
ye kill, and covet, and cannot obtain:---This statement, insofar as it refers to murder would best be construed as figurative; it is most unlikely that James intended to charge wholesale murder upon the people to whom he wrote. If the word "kill" is to be interpreted literally, then the writer was describing the situation which normally follows when men are influenced by evil desire. What James appears to mean here is that the motive which urged them on was murderous in its nature, and the disposition which leads men to murder. A further difficulty arises in the order of words here which, on the surface, would appear to be transposed, inasmuch as killing is regarded as a more serious crime than coveting. Why "kill and covet," rather than "Covet and kill?" A simple solution is to be found in the rearrangement of the punctuation of the passage, thus making it to read,
"Ye lust, and have not!
Ye kill;
Ye covet and cannot obtain. "
In which case, killing whether literal or figurative, is thus shown to be the result of improper desire and the failure to obtain that thus coveted; and avoided is the inversion which the punctuation of the ASV (uninspired, of course), creates.
"Ye kill," (phoneuete, present active indicative of phoneuo, to murder), is literally, "You engage continuously in killing," and thus indicates that such was the constant practice of this people. But, even this did not secure for them that which they so passionately wanted. "Ye kill, and covet, and cannot obtain."
ye fight and war;---A constant state of conflict prevailed from their efforts to satisfy desire, yet this failed to accomplish their aims. James thus vividly and impressively describes the vicious circles into which these people were caught. They passionately desire things they ought not; to satisfy the desire, they maintain a constant state of strife and warfare; but, this does not obtain for them their wants. Verse 2, is thus in close connection with verse 1, and denotes the relationship obtaining between desire and confiict. The latter is the result of the former, and its inevitable fruit. Where improper desire obtains, there will be strife.
Thus shown is the certain consequence of choosing pleasure to the neglect of God. The Bible abounds with illustrations indicating the fatal consequence of such a choice. Among them are Cain, Baalam, and the Israelites in the wilderness.
ye have not, because ye ask not.-From this section we learn that there are not only unanswered prayers, there are also unaskrd prayers! It is evident that proper desire may be experienced and satisfied by praying to God who alone can supply the soul's innermost need. There are some things it is entirely proper for us to have; God wants us to have them; and he freely bestows them upon those who ask. Some seek to secure to themselves the things they want and perhaps need by methods which avoid God; and thus often fail to have such, not because they are forbidden to them, but because they simply do not go to the right source for them. We must, of course, (a) desire the right things; (b) we must ask God for the things which he graciously has for us (James 1:5); (c) and we must have confidence that he will hear and answer our petitions (1 John 4:14-15). God will answer the prayer of the penitent (Luke 18:14), the cry of the righteous (Psalms 34 : lS), and those who keep on asking for their needs (Matthew 7:7).
Here, indeed, is indisputable evidence of the efficacy of prayer. In its effectiveness James believed implicitly, and was, by the Holy Spirit, led to pen one of the strongest statements in Scripture regarding it: "The supplication of a righteous man availeth much in its working." (James 5:16.) "Ye ask not," in our text, is in a construction where the action is performed in behalf of one's own self; and thus indicates a disregard for that which would be for their good were they to follow the Lord's way. They would not pray for legitimate needs; therefore, God would not give them such; and they could not obtain them in other ways. Men who disregard God and seek by shortcuts, as did Esau, to obtain that which God will, under proper circumstances, bestow, must always find the satisfaction for which the heart sighs just beyond reach. Thus, the right way to obtain anything we need is to ask God for it; and, when we have so done, and the petition is not granted, we should conclude that God does not regard the object as necessary for our need; or, that he intends to give us something far better late.
We learn here, (1) those of whom James wrote were guilty of lust, murder, covetousness, fighting and strife. Though continuously torn by overwhelming desires, they failed to obtain that which they wanted; though they coveted that which others possessed, they did not obtain; and (2) their lives were consequently barren and prayerless. It should be observed that each of the clauses of verse 2 is closely related in meaning: They wish for that which they do not have; they seek to obtain it improperly and by force and this results in strife and war. The desire to possess those things which they did not have led to sin, even as it does today. There are two reasons assigned why they did not have the things which they needed: (I) they sought for them in sinful fashion; (2) they did not ask God to give them needed blessing. Jesus has promised us such things as we need, when we ask for them in the right manner (Matthew 7:7; Matthew 21:22) ; and if these results do not follow our prayers, it is because (a) we do not pray properly; or (b) because, as in this case, we do not pray at all.
Let us remember that some prayers are unanswered; others are unasked. We should, of course, want only the things God wants us to have, and to ask him for no others. In this manner alone may the heart's deepest needs be realized.
3 Ye ask, and receive not,---Some, among those of whom Jam es wrote did not recieve, because they did not ask; others asked but did not receive. If we are disposed to be shocked by the suggestion that men may be lustful, covetous, murderers (at heart) and constant wranglers and, at the same time, be given to prayer, we need only to recall that it is not unusual for men to invoke the blessings of God upon them, though engaged in the most highhanded wickedness. In medieval times particularly, multitudes of people were slaughtered in the name of religion; and campaigns were launched on the pretense of doing God's will. "Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye build the sepulchres of the prophets, and garnish the tombs of the righteous, and say, If we had been in the days of our fathers, we should not have been partakers with them in the blood of the prophets. Wherefore ye witness to yourselves, that ye are sons of them that slew the prophets. Fill ye up then the measure of your fathers. Ye serpents, ye offspring oi vipers, how shall ye escape the judgment of hell? Therefore, behold, I send unto you prophets, and wise men, and scribes: some of them shall ye kill and crucify; and some of them shall ye scourge in your synagogues, and persecute from city to city: that upon you may come all the righteous blood shed on the earth, from the blood of Abel the righteous unto the blood of Zachariah the son of Barachiah, whom ye slew between the sanctuary and the altar." (Matthew 23:29-35.) "They shall put you out of the synagogues : yea, the hour cometh, that whosoever killeth you shall think that he offereth service unto God." (John 16:2.)
Our Lord said, "For where thy treasure is, there will thy heart be also." (Matthew 6:21.) If our interests are largely centered in the things of the earth, we will be disposed chiefly to seek for such things; and, if we pray at all, to pray for them. These of whom James wrote were motivated by the desire for material things; and jealousy, envy and strife characterized them in the search. From this we learn that it is quite possible for those who have obeyed the gospel to give attention to the wrong things in their quest for happiness. Jesus said, "But seek ye first his kingdom, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you." (Matthew 6:33.) The word "added," in this passage is, from the Greek word prostithemi, the meaning of which is very near our Southern provincialism, to boot, something thrown in extra to make the bargain more attractive. Jesus thus promises us that if we put his affairs first he will give us our material needs to boot, in addition to our salvation! \Ve are assured that God will answer the prayers of his people. Jesus said, "Ask, and it shall be given you ; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you; for every one that asketh receiveth; and he that seeketh findeth ; and to him that knocketh it shall be opened." (Matthew 7:7-8.) We must, however, understand that these promises are conditioned on (a) asking for the right things, (b) in the right way, and (c) from right motives. The verb aiteite, "ye ask," means to request, to beg; and is the usual word where one, consciously inferior, makes a petition to one regarded as superior. (Acts 12:20; Matthew 7:9; 1 John 3:22.) It is of significance that our Lord never used this term in his petitions to the Father in behalf of the disciples; his approach was on the basis of a Son before his Father.
One may, however, ask for the right things, and the prayer still be improper because of wrong motives. These of whom James wrote asked, but in the wrong fashion.
because ye ask amiss,---(dioti kakos aiteisthe, because ye ask evilly.) Here, the verb aiteo, to ask, is in the middle voice, to ask for one's self. We thus learn that where selfishness is involved petitions to God are fruitless. God will not grant a request the purpose of which is to satisfy selfish desire. "Amiss," (kakos) designates that which is base or mean. To ask amiss is, therefore, to be influenced by low, mean, selfish considerations. This is a general statement explaining why those of whom James wrote did not receive that for which they prayed; in the statement which follows in the text the reason why their petitions were regarded as improper is indicated.
that ye may spend it in your pleasures.---(Hina en tais hedonais humon dapanesete, a purpose clause, introduced with hina, the verb of which is dapanesete, aorist subjunctive, signifying to consume wastefully, to squander.) Thus, that which is to be used by us for purely selfish gratification is, by our Lord, regarded as squandered, wasted; and, obviously, God is not going to give us that which is to be wasted! "Pleasures," here is the same word as that occurring in verse 1, and means desires of a fleshly, sensual nature, satisfied. Whether, therefore, God grants a petition for health, wealth, the ability to serve, depends on the motive which prompts such a petition. It is possible for one to pray for ability to serve others when the chief reason for the desire is not the welfare of man, but lust for power, fame, notoriety, etc. God will not answer such prayers, because they are evilly motivated. Those who thus ask, ask amiss.
It is vitally important that we be impressed with the realization that God will not hear and answer a prayer which has, as its chief motive, the gratification of fleshly desire. Such appears to have been the design of those to whom James refers in our text. This does not mean that God will never hear and answer a prayer involviµg material matters. The inspired writer does not rebuke his readers for asking God to prosper them materially. It is the motive which determines whether such a prayer is proper or not. If we ask in order that we may consume the blessings upon our lusts, he will not hear.
If it is for our welfare, or the welfare of others and the cause of Christ it is in order for us so to pray. John prayed that his friend Gaius "in all things" would "prosper and be in health," even as his "soul prospereth." (3 John 1:2.) We are thus encouraged to bring our temporal needs to the Lord, with the assurance that if such are for our good he will bestow them freely and graciously.
We must, however, examine our motives with extreme care, for it is difficult for us to separate our needs from our desires, and to feel that the design is the former, when it is, in reality, the latter. Prayer is a marvelous privilege of every faithful child of God, and ought to be utilized regularly. We must always remember that there are well defined conditions with which we are to comply, if we may properly expect an answer. Those of whom James wrote did not obtain an answer to their petitions because they asked "amiss," (evilly, from wrong motives.) When petitions are conceived in greed, and expressed hypocritically, God always turns a deaf ear. Only those prayers which have as their aim the glory of God, the advancement of his cause, and the genuine well being of his followers, ascend to the throne of grace, and bring a blessing. Our prayers reveal, in striking detail, and great accuracy, the character of our hearts to ourselves, to others, and to God.