Orthodoxus. How, then, do you say it was that He left the qualities of evil as they were?
Was it that He was able to do away with them, or that, though He wished to do so, He was
unable? For if you say that He was able, but disinclined to do so, He must be the author of
these things; because, while He had power to bring evil to an end, He allowed it to remain
as it was, especially when He had begun to work upon matter. For if He had had nothing at
all to do with matter, He would not have been the author of what He allowed to remain.
But since He works upon a part of it, and leaves a part of it to itself, while He has power to
change it for the better, I think He is the author of evil, since He left part of matter in its
vileness. He wrought then for the ruin of a part; and, in this respect, it seems to me that this
part was chiefly injured by His arranging it in matter, so that it became partaker of evil. For
before matter was put in order, it was without the perception of evil; but now each of its
parts has the capacity of perceiving evil. Now, take an example in the case of man. Previously
to becoming a living creature, he was insensible to evil; but from the time when he is fash-
ioned by God into the form of man, he gains the perception of approaching evil. So this act
of God, which you say was done for the benefit of matter, is found to have happened to it
rather for the worse. But if you say that God was not able to stop evil, does the impossibility
result from His being naturally weak, or from His being overcome by fear, and in subjection
to some more powerful being? See which of these you would like to attribute to the almighty
and good God. But, again, answer me about matter. Is matter simple or compound? For if
matter be simple and uniform, and the universe compound, and composed of different
substances, it is impossible to say that it is made of matter, because compound things cannot
be composed of one pure and simple ingredient. For composition indicates the mixture of
several simple things. But if, on the other hand, you say that matter is compound, it has
been entirely composed of simple elements, and they were once each separately simple, and
by their composition matter was produced; for compound things derive their composition
from simple things. So there was once a time when matter did not exist—that is to say, before
the combination of the simple elements. But if there was once a time when matter did not
exist, and there was never a time when what is uncreated did not exist, then matter is not
uncreated. And from this it follows that there are many things which are uncreated. For if
God were uncreated, and the simple elements of which matter was composed were uncreated,
the number of the uncreated would be more than two. But to omit inquiring what are the
simple elements, matter or form—for this would be followed by many absurdities—let me
ask, do you think that nothing that exists is contrary to itself?
Valentinian. I do.
Orthodoxus. Yet water is contrary to fire, and darkness to light, and heat to cold, and
moisture to dryness.
Valentinian. I think it is.
819
Concerning Free-Will.