Simon Magus, of whom mention is first made in Acts viii. 9 sqq. (quoted
above, in chap. 1), played a very prominent role in early Church
history. His life has been so greatly embellished with legends that it
is very difficult to extract a trustworthy account of him. Indeed the
Tübingen school, as well as some other modern critics, have denied
altogether the existence of such a personage, and have resolved the
account of him into a Jewish Christian fiction produced in hostility to
the apostle Paul, who under the mask of Simon was attacked as the real
heretic. But this identification of Paul and Simon rests upon a very
slender foundation, as many passages can be adduced in which the two
are expressly distinguished, and indeed the thought of identifying Paul
and Simon seems never to have occurred to the writer of the
Recognitions. The most that can be said is that the author of
the Homilies gives, and without doubt purposely, some Pauline
traits to his picture of Simon, but this does not imply that he makes
Simon no more than a mask for Paul (cf. the words of Salmon in his
article, Clementine Literature, in the Dict. of Christ.
Biog. Vol. I. p. 576). The original of Simon then is not to be
found in Paul. The third century fiction is based upon a real historic
person whose actual existence must be assumed to account for the early
notices of him in the Acts and in Justin Martyr, as well as the common
tradition of him among all parties in the Church. Salmon considers
Simon of Gitton—the basis of the account of Justin Martyr and of
all the later Simon legends—a second century Gnostic distinct
from the Simon mentioned in the Acts (see his excellent article
Simon Magus, in the Dict. of Christ. Biog. IV. p. 681
sqq.). In the Pseudo-Clementines Simon is represented as traveling
widely and spreading his errors in all directions, while Peter follows
him for the purpose of exposing his impostures, and refutes him
repeatedly in public disputations, until at length he conquers him
completely in Rome, and Simon ends his life by suicide. His death, as
well as his life, is recorded in various conflicting and fabulous
traditions (see note 9, below). For ancient accounts of Simon, see
Justin Martyr, Apol. I. 26 and 56 and Dial. c. Trypho.
CXX.; the Pseudo-Clementine Homilies and Recognitions;
Irenæus, I. 23; Hippolytus, VI. 2 sq.; Tertullian’s
Apology, On Idolatry, On the Soul, etc.; Apost.
Constitutions, VII. 7 sq.; Arnobius, Adv. Gentes, II. 12,
&c.; Acts of the Holy Apostles Peter and Paul (Ante-Nicene
Fathers, Am. ed. VIII. p. 477 sqq.); Epiphanius, Hær.
XXI.; and Theodoret, Hær. Fab. I. 1. See also Lipsius,
article in Schinkel’s Bibel-Lexicon, Vol. V.