Chapter 23.—What We are to Think of the Example of Cato, Who Slew Himself Because
Unable to Endure Cæsar’s Victory.
Besides Lucretia, of whom enough has already been said, our advocates of suicide have
some difficulty in finding any other prescriptive example, unless it be that of Cato, who
killed himself at Utica. His example is appealed to, not because he was the only man who
did so, but because he was so esteemed as a learned and excellent man, that it could plausibly
be maintained that what he did was and is a good thing to do. But of this action of his, what
can I say but that his own friends, enlightened men as he, prudently dissuaded him, and
therefore judged his act to be that of a feeble rather than a strong spirit, and dictated not by
honorable feeling forestalling shame, but by weakness shrinking from hardships? Indeed,
Cato condemns himself by the advice he gave to his dearly loved son. For if it was a disgrace
to live under Cæsar’s rule, why did the father urge the son to this disgrace, by encouraging
him to trust absolutely to Cæsar’s generosity? Why did he not persuade him to die along
with himself? If Torquatus was applauded for putting his son to death, when contrary to
orders he had engaged, and engaged successfully, with the enemy, why did conquered Cato
spare his conquered son, though he did not spare himself? Was it more disgraceful to be a
victor contrary to orders, than to submit to a victor contrary to the received ideas of honor?
Cato, then, cannot have deemed it to be shameful to live under Cæsar’s rule; for had he done
so, the father’s sword would have delivered his son from this disgrace. The truth is, that his
son, whom he both hoped and desired would be spared by Cæsar, was not more loved by
him than Cæsar was envied the glory of pardoning him (as indeed Cæsar himself is reported
to have said79); or if envy is too strong a word, let us say he was ashamed that this glory
should be his.
79 Plutarch’s Life of Cato, 72.
What We are to Think of the Example of Cato, Who Slew Himself Because Unable to Endure Cæsar’s Victory.
53
What We are to Think of the Example of Cato, Who Slew Himself Because Unable…