though upon the property of a Catholic woman, he neither replied nor allowed others to
resent the insult.
A practical treatise is ascribed by some to this time, called de Agone Christiano. In ex-
pounding the faith he warns against different groups of heretics and schismatics. In Chap.
xxix. 31, he cautions against listening to the Donatist party, who deny the one holy Catholic
church to be diffused throughout the whole world, and claim it to be alone in Africa, and
there among themselves, against the plain Scripture teaching of its universality; they affirm
that the prophecies of its extension have already been fulfilled, after which the whole church
perished outside of their remnant. He alludes to the divisions which have befallen them as
a retribution for their separation. If the end shall come after the preaching of the gospel to
all nations, how can all nations have lapsed from the faith, when there remain some who
are yet to hear and believe? This system robs Christ of His glory, and is to be avoided by all
who love the Church. (Cp. Retractt. II. iii.).
In 397 A.D., at the death of Valerius, he became sole bishop. In this year, while on a
visit to Tibursi, he had met with Glorius and other Donatists, with whom he held a friendly
disputation on the origin and history of the schism, during which some Donatist documents
were produced which he declared to be false, and from memory recapitulated the archives
current on his side. Augustin pursued his journey to Gelizi, where he attended to some
episcopal duties, and brought back with him a copy of the Catholic Gesta, and spent a day
with these friends in reading them, but could not quite finish. He subsequently reproduces
this story with the arguments in a letter. (Ep. xliii.). The chief burden is a criticism of the
Acts, highly important in its place, but it must be passed by here save to remark that in
speaking of Bishop Secundus, he suggests that it would have been better to appeal to the
principalities of Rome or of some other apostolic church, than to have proceeded as he did;
377
he should have preserved the unity at all hazards; had the case been inexplicable, he should
have left it to God; if definable, he should have addressed the transmarine bishops, after
finding that his peers at home could not adjust the difficulty; disobedience on the part of
Cæcilian to such an order, would have made him the author of the schism; but now the
Donatist altar is set up against the Universal Church. It may be well to note that throughout
the survey of these acts, there appears a manifest contradiction as to the beginning of the
appellations. In the next place, the Donatists are held guilty of schism, rebaptism, and res-
istance to civil correction; of non-communion with those churches concerning whom they
read in their lections; and of the demand for purism against the Lord’s parable. The angels
of the churches in the apocalypse are ecclesiastical powers, not heavenly messengers. The
Church cannot be charged with the crimes of the evil men in it. Toleration is the only
practice by which unity can be conserved; Moses bore with murmurers, David with Saul,
Samuel with the sons of Eli, Christ with Judas. They themselves forbear with Circumcelliones,
with Optatus bishop of Thamugada. The emphasis, however, is not so much upon those
653
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.