Chapter 28.—What Plato or Labeo, or Even Varro, Might Have Contributed to the True
Faith of the Resurrection, If They Had Adopted One Another’s Opinions into One Scheme.
Some Christians, who have a liking for Plato on account of his magnificent style and
the truths which he now and then uttered, say that he even held an opinion similar to our
own regarding the resurrection of the dead. Cicero, however, alluding to this in his Republic,
asserts that Plato meant it rather as a playful fancy than as a reality; for he introduces a
man1668 who had come to life again, and gave a narrative of his experience in corroboration
of the doctrines of Plato. Labeo, too, says that two men died on one day, and met at a cross-
road, and that, being afterwards ordered to return to their bodies, they agreed to be friends
for life, and were so till they died again. But the resurrection which these writers instance
resembles that of those persons whom we have ourselves known to rise again, and who came
back indeed to this life, but not so as never to die again. Marcus Varro, however, in his
work On the Origin of the Roman People, records something more remarkable; I think his
own words should be given. “Certain astrologers,” he says, “have written that men are
destined to a new birth, which the Greeks call palingenesy. This will take place after four
hundred and forty years have elapsed; and then the same soul and the same body, which
were formerly united in the person, shall again be reunited.” This Varro, indeed, or those
nameless astrologers,—for he does not give us the names of the men whose statement he
cites,—have affirmed what is indeed not altogether true; for once the souls have returned
to the bodies they wore, they shall never afterwards leave them. Yet what they say upsets
and demolishes much of that idle talk of our adversaries about the impossibility of the re-
507
surrection. For those who have been or are of this opinion, have not thought it possible
that bodies which have dissolved into air, or dust, or ashes, or water, or into the bodies of
the beasts or even of the men that fed on them, should be restored again to that which they
formerly were. And therefore, if Plato and Porphyry, or rather, if their disciples now living,
agree with us that holy souls shall return to the body, as Plato says, and that, nevertheless,
they shall not return to misery, as Porphyry maintains, —if they accept the consequence of
these two propositions which is taught by the Christian faith, that they shall receive bodies
in which they may live eternally without suffering any misery,—let them also adopt from
Varro the opinion that they shall return to the same bodies as they were formerly in, and
thus the whole question of the eternal resurrection of the body shall be resolved out of their
own mouths.
1668 In the Republic, x.
What Plato or Labeo, or Even Varro, Might Have Contributed to the True Faith of the Resurrection, If They Had Adopted One Another’s Opinions into One Scheme.
1132
What Plato or Labeo, or Even Varro, Might Have Contributed to the True Faith…