Now these points being conceded
to us, the further point is also clear to any one, that, as Moses says
darkness was before the creation of light, so also in the case of the
Son (if, according to the heretical statement, the Father “made
Him at that time when He willed”), before He made Him, that Light
which the Son is was not; and, light not yet being, it is impossible
that its opposite should not be. For we learn also from the other
instances that nothing that comes from the Creator is at random, but
that which was lacking is added by creation to existing things. Thus it
is quite clear that if God did make the Son, He made Him by reason of a
deficiency in the nature of things. As, then, while sensible light was
still lacking, there was darkness, and darkness would certainly have
prevailed had light not come into being, so also, when the Son
“as yet was not,” the very and true Light, and all else
that the Son is, did not exist. For even according to the evidence of
heresy, that which exists has no need of coming into being; if
therefore He made Him, He assuredly made that which did not exist.
Thus, according to their view, before the Son came into being, neither
had truth come into being, nor the intelligible Light, nor the fount of
life, nor, generally, the nature of any thing that is excellent and
good. Now, concurrently with the exclusion of each of these, there is
found to subsist the opposite conception: and if light was not, it
cannot be denied that darkness was; and so with the
rest,—in place of each of these more excellent conceptions it is
clearly impossible that its opposite did not exist in place of that
which was lacking. It is therefore a necessary conclusion, that when
the Father, as the heretics say, “had not as yet willed to make
the Son,” none of those things which the Son is being yet
existent, we must say that He was surrounded by darkness instead of
Light, by falsehood instead of truth, by death instead of life, by evil
instead of good. For He Who creates, creates things that are not;
“That which is,” as Eunomius says, “needs not
generation”; and of those things which are considered as opposed,
the better cannot be non-existent, except by the existence of the
worse. These are the gifts with which the wisdom of heresy honours the
Father, by which it degrades the eternity of the Son, and ascribes to
God and the Father, before the “production” of the Son, the
whole catalogue of evils!