Chapter VII.—The Emperor Constantine being grieved at the Disturbance of the Churches,
sends Hosius the Spaniard to Alexandria, exhorting the Bishop and Arius to Reconciliation
and Unity.
When the emperor was made acquainted with these disorders, he was very deeply
grieved; and regarding the matter as a personal misfortune, immediately exerted himself to
extinguish the conflagration which had been kindled, and sent a letter to Alexander and
Arius by a trustworthy person named Hosius, who was bishop of Cordova, in Spain. The
emperor greatly loved this man and held him in the highest estimation. It will not be out of
place to introduce here a portion of this letter, the whole of which is given in the life of
Constantine by Eusebius.143
Victor Constantine Maximum Augustus to Alexander and Arius.
I am informed that your present controversy originated thus. When you, Alexander,
inquired of your presbyters what each thought on a certain inexplicable passage of the
written Word, rather on a subject improper for discussion; and you, Arius, rashly gave ex-
pression to a view of the matter such as ought either never to have been conceived, or when
suggested to your mind, it became you to bury it in silence. This dispute having thus been
excited among you, communion144 has been denied; and the most holy people being rent
into two factions, have departed from the harmony of the common body. Wherefore let
each one of you, showing consideration for the other, listen to the impartial exhortation of
your fellow-servant. And what counsel does he offer? It was neither prudent at first to agitate
such a question, nor to reply to such a question when proposed: for the claim of no law de-
mands the investigation of such subjects, but the idle useless talk of leisure occasions them.
And even if they should exist for the sake of exercising our natural faculties, yet we ought
to confine them to our own consideration, and not incautiously bring them forth in public
assemblies, nor thoughtlessly confide them to the ears of everybody. Indeed how few are
capable either of adequately expounding, or even accurately understanding the import of
matters so vast and profound!
And even if any one should be considered able to satisfactorily accomplish this, how
large a portion of the people would he succeed in convincing? Or who can grapple with the
subtilties of such investigations without danger of lapsing into error? It becomes us therefore
on such topics to check loquacity, lest either on account of the weakness of our nature we
should be incompetent to explain the subject proposed; or the dull understanding of the
audience should make them unable to apprehend clearly what is attempted to be taught:
and in the case of one or the other of these failures, the people must be necessarily involved
either in blasphemy or schism. Wherefore let an unguarded question, and an inconsiderate
143 Euseb. Life of Const. II. 64–72.
144 σύνοδος; lit., ‘coming together.’
The Emperor Constantine being grieved at the Disturbance of the Churches, sends Hosius the Spaniard to Alexandria, exhorting the Bishop and Arius to Reconciliation and Unity.
35
The Emperor Constantine being grieved at the Disturbance of the Churches,…