43. This is sufficient to shew that the meaning
of the beloved ones §54, note 2. is not foreign nor
far from the ‘Coessential.’ But since, as they allege Vid.
Hilar. de Syn. 81 init.; Epiph. Hær. 73.
12. (for I have not the Epistle in question),
the Bishops who condemned the Samosatene There
were three Councils held against Paul of Samosata, of the dates of 264,
269, and an intermediate year. The third is spoken of in the text,
which contrary to the opinion of Pagi, S. Basnage, and Tillemont,
Pearson fixes at 265 or 266.
have said in writing that the Son is not coessential with the Father,
and so it comes to pass that they, for caution and honour towards those
who have so said, thus feel about that expression, it will be to the
purpose cautiously to argue with them this point also. Certainly it is
unbecoming to make the one conflict with the others; for all are
fathers; nor is it religious to settle, that these have spoken well,
and those ill; for all of them fell asleep in Christ. Nor is it right
to be disputatious, and to compare the respective numbers of those who
met in the Councils, lest the three hundred seem to throw the lesser
into the shade; nor to compare the dates, lest those who preceded seem
to eclipse those that came after. For all, I say, are fathers; and yet
not even the three hundred laid down nothing new, nor was it in any
self-confidence that they became champions of words not in Scripture,
but they fell back upon fathers, as did the others, and used their
words. For there have been two of the name of Dionysius, much older
than the seventy who deposed the Samosatene, of whom one was of Rome,
and the other of Alexandria. But a charge had been laid by some persons
against the Bishop of Alexandria before the Bishop of Rome, as if he
had said that the Son was made, and not coessential with the Father.
And, the synod at Rome being indignant, the Bishop of Rome expressed
their united sentiments in a letter to his namesake. And so the latter,
in defence, wrote a book with the title ‘of Refutation and
Defence;’ and thus he writes to the other: