But here a singular discussion arises between the
eminent Cardinals Bellarmine and Baronius. The latter, and with
him a large number of our theologians, recognize the letter of Leo as
the Type and Rule of faith, by which all Churches were bound: but
Bellarmine, alarmed at the examination which he could not deny, answers
thus: “Leo had sent his letter to the council, not as
containing his final and definitive sentence, but as an instruction,
assisted by which the bishops might form a better
judgment.” But, most eminent man, allow me to say that Leo,
upon the appeal of Eutyches, and at the demand of Flavian, composed
this letter for a summary of the faith, and sent it to every Church in
all parts, when as yet no one thought about a council. Therefore
it was not an instruction to the council which he provided, but an
Apostolic sentence which he put forth. The fact is that out of
this strait there was no other escape: Baronius will not allow
that a letter, confirmed by so great an authority of the Apostolic See,
should be attributed to any other power but that which is supreme and
indefectible: Bellarmine will not take that to emanate from the
supreme and indefectible authority, which was subjected to synodical
inquiry, and deliberation. What, then, is the issue of this
conflict, unless that it is equally evident that the letter was written
with the whole authority of the Apostolic See, and yet subjected, as
usual, to the examination of an Universal Council.