The
argument here takes the form of a reductio ad absurdum; assuming
that S. Peter’s reference is to the “visible man,”
and bearing in mind S. Basil’s words that S. Peter refers to Him
Who “emptied Himself,” it is said “then it was the
‘visible man’ who ‘emptied himself.’ But the
purpose of that ‘emptying’ was the ‘taking the form
of a servant,’ which again is the coming into being as man:
therefore the ‘visible man’ ‘emptied himself,’
to come into being as man, which is absurd.” The wording of S.
Basil’s statement makes the argument in a certain degree
plausible;—if he had said that S. Peter referred to the Son, not
in regard to his actual essence, but in regard to the fact that He
“emptied Himself” to become man, and as so having
“emptied Himself” (which is no doubt what he intended his
words to mean), then the reductio ad absurdum would not apply;
nor would the later arguments, by which Eunomius proceeds to prove that
He Who “emptied Himself” was no mere man, but the Word Who
was in the beginning, have any force as against S. Basil’s
statement.