XX. What was the life in Paradise, and what was the forbidden tree1676?
1. What then is that which includes the knowledge of good and evil blended together,
and is decked with the pleasures of sense? I think I am not aiming wide of the mark in em-
ploying, as a starting-point for my speculation, the sense of “knowable1677.” It is not, I think,
“science” which the Scripture here means by “knowledge”; but I find a certain distinction,
409
according to Scriptural use, between “knowledge” and “discernment”: for to “discern” skilfully
the good from the evil, the Apostle says is a mark of a more perfect condition and of “exer-
cised senses1678,” for which reason also he bids us “prove all things1679,” and says that
“discernment” belongs to the spiritual man1680: but “knowledge” is not always to be under-
stood of skill and acquaintance with anything, but of the disposition towards what is
agreeable,—as “the Lord knoweth them that are His1681”; and He says to Moses, “I knew
thee above all1682”; while of those condemned in their wickedness He Who knows all things
says, “I never knew you1683.”
2. The tree, then, from which comes this fruit of mixed knowledge, is among those
things which are forbidden; and that fruit is combined of opposite qualities, which has the
serpent to commend it, it may be for this reason, that the evil is not exposed in its nakedness,
itself appearing in its own proper nature—for wickedness would surely fail of its effect were
it not decked with some fair colour to entice to the desire of it him whom it deceives—but
now the nature of evil is in a manner mixed, keeping destruction like some snare concealed
in its depths, and displaying some phantom of good in the deceitfulness of its exterior. The
beauty of the substance seems good to those who love money: yet “the love of money is a
root of all evil1684”: and who would plunge into the unsavoury mud of wantonness, were it
not that he whom this bait hurries into passion thinks pleasure a thing fair and acceptable?
so, too, the other sins keep their destruction hidden, and seem at first sight acceptable, and
some deceit makes them earnestly sought after by unwary men instead of what is good.
1676 Otherwise Chap. xxi. The Bodleian ms. of the Latin version gives as the title:—“Why Scripture calls the
tree, ‘the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.’”
1677 The reference is to Gen. ii. 9 (in LXX.), where the tree is called, τὸ ξύλον τοῦ εἰδέναι γνωστὸν καλοῦ
καὶ πονηροῦ. S. Gregory proceeds to ascertain the exact meaning of the word γνωστὸν in the text; the eating is
the “knowing,” but what is “knowing”? He answers, “desiring.”
1678 Cf. Heb. v. 14
1679 1 Thess v. 21.
1680 Cf. 1 Cor. ii. 15.
1681 2 Tim. ii. 19.
1682 Ex. xxxiii. 12 (LXX.).
1683 S. Matt. vii. 23.
1684 1 Tim. vi. 10.
What was the life in Paradise, and what was the forbidden tree?
760
What was the life in Paradise, and what was the forbidden tree?