I'ROLEGOMENA. n
religious bisliops with them shouted out : ' Cast out one man, and we will all hear.
We shout out in the cause of Religion. We say these things for the sake of the orthodox
Faith.' The most illustrious Presidents and the honourable Assessors said: 'Rather
acquiesce, in God's name, that the hearing of the documents shoidd take place, and concede
that all shall be read in proper order.' And at last they were silent, and Constantinc,
the most holy Secretary and Magistrate of the Divine Synod, read these documents."'
One more sad incident must be given — the demand made at the eighth session that
Theodoret should pronounce a curse on his ancient friend. " The most reverend bishops
all stood before the rails of the most holy altar, and shouted " Theodoret must now
anathematize Nestorius." Theodoret, the most reverend bishop, passed into the midst,
and said: "I have made my petition to the most divine and religious Emperor,
and I have laid documents before the most reverend bishops occupying
the place of the most sacred Archbishop Leo ; and if you think fit, they
shall be read to you, and you will know what I think.' The most
reverend bishops shouted 'We want nothing to be read — only anathematize Nestori-
us.' Theodoret, the most reverend bishop, said : ' I was brought up by the ortho- dox, I was taught by the orthodox, I have preached orthodoxy, and not only
Nestorius and Eutyches, but any man who thmks not rightly, I avoid and count him an
alien.' The most reverend bishops shouted out : ' Speak plainly ; anathema to
Nestorius and his doctrine — anathema to Nestorius and to those who defend him.'
Theodoret, the most reverend bishop said : ' Of a truth I say nothing except so far
as I know it to be pleasing to God. First I will convince you that I am here, not because
I care for my city, not because I covet rank. Because I have been falsely accused, I
come to satisfy you that I am orthodox, and that I anathematize Nestorius and Eutyches,
and every one who says that there are two Sons.' Whilst he was speaking, the most
reverend bisliops shouted out : ' Speak plainly ; anathematize Nestorius and those who
think with him.' Theodoret, the most reverend bishop, said : ' Unless I set forth at
length my faith I cannot speak. I believe' — And whilst he spoke the most reverend
bishops shouted : ' He is a heretic ! He is a Nestorian ! Away with the heretic I An-
athema to Nestorius and to any one who does not confess that the Holy Vn-gin Mary is
the Parent of God, and who divides the only begotten Son into two Sons.' Theodoret,
the most reverend bishop, said, ' Anathema to Nestorius and to whoever denies that the
Holy Virgin Mary is the Parent of God, and who divides the only begotten Son into
two Sons. I have subscribed the definition of faith, and the epistle of the most holy
Archbishop Leo.' " '
VL — Retirement after Chalcedon, and Death.
Some doubt hangs over the question whether after his vindication at Chalcedon
Theodoret resumed his labours at Cyrus, or occupied himself with literary work in the
congenial seclusion of Nicerte. Garnerius makes it about the time of his quitting Chal-
cedon that Sporacius charged him with the duty of writing on the Heresies,^ and if so his five books on this subject would seem to have constituted the first fruit of bis comparative
leisure. Sporacius* he styles his " Christ-loving Son," and no doubt owed something to
the aid of the influential "Comes domesticorum," who was present at Chalcedon, when the question of his admission to the Council was being agitated. To this period has also
been referred his commentary on the Octateuch.' On Dr. Newman's statement that Theodoret made over the charge of his diocese to Hypatius (one of his chorepiscopi, who
had been entrusted with his appeal to Pope Leo) and retired into his monaster)', and
lliere regaining the peace which he had enjoyed in youth, passed from the peace of the
Church to the peace of eternity. Canon Venables" remarks that there is no authority
for so pleasing a picture, and that Tillemont ' contradicts it altogether. Garnerius quotes
his congratulation to Sabinianus ' on leaving Perrhaas suggestive of what conduct he might have preferred.
It is at least certain that during this periotl he received a long and sympathetic letter from
1 Labbe, iv., 102, 103.
»Labho iv. 621. Bertram (Tlieod. Ep. Cyr. doctrina christolojrica, 1S33) thinks Theodoret changed his views; Moli'Jf Herzo); XV. s.v.) that he retained them, though necessarily modified in expression by stress of circumstaQCes.
2 Prif. Harct, Fab. ' Ep. XCVII.
^ Pholius Cod. 2P4. The Octateuch comprises the first eight books of tlic Old Testament.
• Diet. Christ. Biog. iv, 916. » xv., 311. » Ep. CXXVl.