that he now has without hindrance the utmost freedom in that misconduct from which in
the Catholic Church he was restrained. Perhaps Proculeianus knows nothing about this case
either. Let it therefore through you, as a man of grave and dispassionate spirit, be made
known to him; and let him order that man to be dismissed from his communion, who has
chosen it for no other reason than that he had, on account of insubordination and dissolute
habits, forfeited his clerical office in the Catholic Church.
3. For my own part, if it please the Lord, I purpose to adhere to this rule, that whoever,
after being deposed among them by a sentence of discipline, shall express a desire to pass
over into the Catholic Church, must be received on condition of submitting to give the same
proofs of penitence as those which, perhaps, they would have constrained him to give if he
had remained among them. But consider, I beseech you, how worthy of abhorrence is their
procedure in regard to those whom we check by ecclesiastical censures for unholy living,
persuading them first to come to a second baptism, in order to their being qualified for
which they declare themselves to be pagans (and how much blood of martyrs has been
poured out rather than that such a declaration should proceed from the mouth of a Christi-
an!); and thereafter, as if renewed and sanctified, but in truth more hardened in sin, to defy
with the impiety of new madness, under the guise of new grace, that discipline to which
they could not submit. If, however, I am wrong in attempting to obtain the correction of
these abuses through your benevolent interposition, let no one find fault with my causing
them to be made known to Proculeianus by the public registers,—a means of notification
which in this Roman city cannot, I believe, be refused to me. For, since the Lord commands
us to speak and proclaim the truth, and in teaching to rebuke what is wrong, and to labour
in season and out of season, as I can prove by the words of the Lord and of the apostles,1568
let no man think that I am to be persuaded to be silent concerning these things. If they
meditate any bold measures of violence or outrage, the Lord, who has subdued under His
yoke all earthly kingdoms in the bosom of His Church spread abroad through the whole
world, will not fail to defend her from wrong.
4. The daughter of one of the cultivators of the property of the Church here, who had
been one of our catechumens, had been, against the will of her parents, drawn away by the
other party, and after being baptized among them, had assumed the profession of a nun.
Now her father wished to compel her by severe treatment to return to the Catholic Church;
265
but I was unwilling that this woman, whose mind was so perverted, should be received by
us unless with her own will, and choosing, in the free exercise of judgment, that which is
better: and when the countryman began to attempt to compel his daughter by blows to
submit to his authority, I immediately forbade his using any such means. Notwithstanding,
after all, when I was passing through the Spanian district, a presbyter of Proculeianus,
1568 2 Tim. iv. 2 and Tit. i. 9–11.
606
To Eusebius