Table B shews the deliberate and careful
calculation which runs through the system of our annalist. Once or
twice he indulges in a round figure, exiles 1 and 5 are each a day too
long by the Egyptian calendar, and this is set off by his apparently
reckoning the fifth quiet period as two days too short. But the writer
clearly knew his own mind. In fact, the one just ground on which we
might distrust his chronology is its systematic character. He has a
thorough scheme of his own, which he carries out to a nicety. Now such
a chronology is not necessarily untrustworthy. Its consistency
may be artificial; on the other hand, it may be due to accurate
knowledge of the facts. Whether this is so or not must be ascertained
partly from a writer’s known opportunities and capacity, partly
from his agreement or discrepancy with other sources of knowledge. Now
our annalist wrote in the time of Theophilus (385–412), and may
therefore rank as a contemporary of Athanasius (cf. Prolegg. ch. v.)
His opportunities therefore were excellent. As to his capacity, his
work bears every trace of care and skill. He is no historian, nor a
stylist, but as an annalist he understood what he was doing. As to
agreement with other data, we remark to begin with that it was the
publication of this fragment in the 18th century that first shed a ray
of light on the Erebus and Chaos of the chronology of the Council of
Sardica and its adjacent events; that it at once justified the critical
genius of Montfaucon, Tillemont and others, against the objections with
which their date for the death of Athanasius But
our annalist gives May 3, while Fest. Ind. gives May 2, the day
solemnised in the Coptic Martyrologies (Mai, Script. Vett. vol.
4, part 2, pp. 29, 114), and doubtless the right one. Perhaps, if
Athanasius died in the night of May 2–3, the former day might be
chosen for his commemoration, while our annalist may still be literally
exact.
was assailed, and here again upset the confused chronological
statements of the fifth-century historians in favour of the incidental
evidence of many more primary authorities See
Tillem. viii. 719 sqq..
But most important of all is its confirmation by the evidence of the
Festal Letters discovered in 1842, and especially by their
Index, the so-called ‘Chronicon Athanasianum.’ It is
evident at a glance that our annalist is quite independent of the
Index, as he gives many details which it does not contain. But
neither can the Index be a compilation from the annalist. Each
writer had access to information not embodied in the other, and there
is no positive evidence that either used the other in any way. When
they agree, therefore, their evidence has the greatest possible weight.
Their main heads of agreement are indicated in the Chronological Table,
Prolegg. sub fin.