It follows from what has been said of the
influence of Origen in moulding the current theology of the Eastern
Church, that the one theological principle which was most vividly and
generally grasped was the horror of Monarchian and especially of
‘Sabellian’ teaching. Now in replying to Asterius the
spokesman of early Arianism, no less a person than Marcellus, bishop of Ancyra (Angora) in Galatia, and one
of the principal leaders of Nicæa, had laid himself open to this
charge. It was brought with zeal and learning (in 336) in two
successive works by Eusebius of Cæsarea, which, with Ath.,
Orat. iv. are our principal source of information as to the
tenets of Marcellus (see D.C.B. ii. 341, sq., Zahn Marcellus 99
sqq., fragments collected by Rettberg Marcelliana). On
the other hand he was uniformly supported by the Nicene party, and
especially by Athanasius and the Roman Church. His book was examined at
Sardica, and on somewhat ex parte grounds (p. 125) pronounced
innocent: a personal estrangement from Athanasius shortly after (Hilar.
Fragm. ii. 21, 23) on account of certain ‘ambiguæ
prædicationes eius, in quam Photinus erupit, doctrinæ,’
did not amount to a formal breach of communion (he is mentioned 14
years later as an exiled Nicene bishop, pp. 256, 271), nor did the
anxious questioning of Epiphanius (see Hær. 72. 4.) succeed
in extracting from the then aged Athanasius more than a significant
smile. He refuses to condemn him, and in arguing against opinions which
appear to be his, he refrains from mentioning the name even of Photinus At the
same time he adopts a certain reserve in speaking of Marcellus, and his
name is absent from the roll of the orthodox, p. 227.. It may
be well therefore to sketch in a few touches what we know of the system
of Marcellus, in order that we may appreciate the relative right of
Eusebius in attacking, and of Athanasius and the Romans in supporting
him. Marcellus is a representative of the traditional theology of Asia
Minor, as we find it in Ignatius and Irenæus (see above, pp.
xxii.–xxiv., xxvi. fin.), and is independent of any influence of,
or rather in conscious reaction against, Origenism. We cannot prove
that he had studied either Ignatius or Irenæus, but we find the
doctrine of ἀνακεφαλαίωσις
with reference to Creation and the Incarnation, and the Ignatian
thought of the Divine Silence, and a general unmistakeable affinity
(cf. Zahn 236–244). Marcellus ‘appeals from Origen to S.
John.’ He begins with the idea of Sonship, as Arius and the
Nicene Council had done. Perceiving that on the one hand Arians and
Origenists alike were led by the idea of Sonship as dependent on
paternal will to infer the inferiority of the Son to the Father, and in
the more extreme case to deny His coeternity, feeling on the other hand
(with Irenæus II. xxviii. 6) our inability to find an idea to
correspond with the relation implied in the eternal Sonship, he turns
to the first chapter of S. John as the classic passage for the
pre-existent nature of Christ. He finds that before the
Incarnation the Saviour is spoken of as Logos only:
accordingly all other designations, even that of Son, must be reserved
for the Incarnate. Moreover (Joh. i. 1) the Word is strictly coeternal, and no
name implying an act (such as γέννησις) can
express the relation of the Word to God. But in view of the Divine
Purpose of Creation and Redemption (for the latter is involved in the
former by the doctrine of ἀνακεφαλαίωσις)
there is a process, a stirring within the divine Monad. The Word which
is potentially (δυναμει) eternally
latent in God proceeds forth in Actuality (ἐνεργεί& 139·), yet
without ceasing to be potentially in God as well. In this ἐνέργεια
δραστική, to which the
word γέννησις may be
applied, begins the great drama of the Universe which rises to the
height of the Incarnation, and which, after the Economy is completed,
and fallen man restored (and more than restored) to the Sonship of God
which he had lost, ends in the return of the Logos to the Father, the
handing over of His Kingdom by the Son, that God may be all in all.