Philip the apostle and Philip the evangelist are here confounded.
That they were really two different men is clear enough from
Luke’s account in the Acts (cf. Acts vi. 2–5, viii.
14–17, and xxi. 8). That it was the
evangelist, and not the apostle, that was buried in Hierapolis may be
assumed upon the following grounds: (1) The evangelist (according
to Acts xxi. 8) had four daughters, who were virgins and prophetesses.
Polycrates speaks here of three daughters, at least two of whom were
virgins, and Proclus, just below, speaks of four daughters who were
prophetesses. (2) Eusebius, just below, expressly identifies the
apostle and evangelist, showing that in his time there was no separate
tradition of the two men. Lightfoot (Colossians, p. 45)
maintains that Polycrates is correct, and that it was the apostle, not
the evangelist, that was buried in Hierapolis; but the reasons which he
gives are trivial and will hardly convince scholars in general.
Certainly we need strong grounds to justify the separation of two men
so remarkably similar so far as their families are concerned. But the
truth is, there is nothing more natural than that later generations
should identify the evangelist with the apostle of the same name, and
should assume the presence of the latter wherever the former was known
to have been. This identification would in itself be a welcome one to
the inhabitants of Hierapolis, and hence it would be assumed there more
readily than anywhere else. Of course it is not impossible that Philip
the apostle also had daughters who were virgins and prophetesses, but
it is far more probable that Polycrates (and possibly Clement too; see
the previous chapter) confounded him with the evangelist,—as
every one may have done for some generations before them. Eusebius at
any rate, historian though he was, saw no difficulty in making the
identification, and certainly it was just as easy for Polycrates and
Clement to do the same. Lightfoot makes something of the fact that
Polycrates mentions only three daughters, instead of four. But the
latter’s words by no means imply that there had not been a fourth
daughter (see note 8, below).