But Eunomius, contending with
this statement of ours, says (the very contrary now of what he said
before), “If God is Father because He has begotten the Son, and
‘Father’ has the same meaning as Ungenerate, God is
Ungenerate because He has begotten the Son, but before He begat Him He
was not Ungenerate.” Observe his method of turning round; how he
pulls his first quibble to pieces, and turns it into the very opposite,
thinking even so to entrap us in a conclusion from which there is no
escape. His first syllogism presented the following absurdity,
“If ‘Father’ means the coming from nothing, then
necessarily it will no longer indicate the having begotten the
Son.” But this last syllogism, by turning (a premiss) into its
contrary, threatens our faith with another absurdity. How, then, does
he pull to pieces his former conclusion The
first syllogism was—
‘Father’ means the
‘coming from nothing;’
(‘Coming from
nothing’ does not mean ‘begetting a Son’)
∴ Father does not mean begetting a Son.
He “pulls to pieces”
this conclusion by taking its logical ‘contrary’ as the
first premiss of his second syllogism; thus—
Father means begetting a
Son;
(Father means ᾽Αγέννητος)
∴ ᾽Αγέννητος
means begetting a Son.
From which it follows that
before that begetting the Almighty was not ᾽Αγέννητος
The conclusion of the last
syllogism also involves the contrary of the 2nd premiss of the
first.
It is to be noticed that
both syllogisms are aimed at Basil’s doctrine,
‘Father’ means ‘coming from nothing.’ Eunomius
strives to show that, in both, such a premiss leads to an absurdity.
But Gregory ridicules both for contradicting each other.?
“If He is ‘Father’ because He has begotten a
Son.” His first syllogism gave us nothing like that; on the
contrary, its logical inference purported to show that if the
Father’s not having been generated was meant by the word Father,
that word could not mean as well the having begotten a Son τὸ μὲν μὴ
δύνασθαι. The negative, absent in Oehler, is recovered from the Turin
Cod.. Thus his first syllogism contained no
intimation whatever that God was Father because He had begotten a Son.
I fail to understand what this argumentative and shrewdly professional
reversal means.