9. For, behold, we take divine Scripture, and
thence discourse with freedom of the religious Faith, and set it up as
a light upon its candlestick, saying:—Very Son of the Father,
natural and genuine, proper to His essence, Wisdom Only-begotten, and
Very and Only Word of God is He; not a creature or work, but an
offspring proper to the Father’s essence. Wherefore He is very
God, existing one [This
is the only occurrence of the word ὁμοούσιος in these three Discourses.] in essence with the
very Father; while other beings, to whom He said, ‘I said ye are
Gods Ps. lxxxii. 6.,’ had this grace from the Father, only
by participation de
Decr. §14 fin.; de Syn. §51. of the Word,
through the Spirit. For He is the expression of the Father’s
Person, and Light from Light, and Power, and very Image of the
Father’s essence. For this too the Lord has said, ‘He that
hath seen Me, hath seen the Father John xiv. 9..’ And He
ever was and is and never was not. For the Father being everlasting,
His Word and His Wisdom must be everlasting de
Decr. 15, note 6..
On the other hand, what have these persons to shew us from the infamous
Thalia? Or, first of all, let them read it themselves, and copy the
tone of the writer; at least the mockery which they will encounter from
others may instruct them how low they have fallen; and then let them
proceed to explain themselves. For what can they say from it, but that
‘God was not always a Father, but became so afterwards; the Son
was not always, for He was not before His generation; He is not from
the Father, but He, as others, has come into subsistence out of
nothing; He is not proper to the Father’s essence, for He is a
creature and work?’ And ‘Christ is not very God, but He, as
others, was made God by participation; the Son has not exact knowledge
of the Father, nor does the Word see the Father perfectly; and neither
exactly understands nor knows the Father. He is not the very and only
Word of the Father, but is in name only called Word and Wisdom, and is
called by grace Son and Power. He is not unalterable, as the Father is,
but alterable in nature, as the creatures, and He comes short of
apprehending the perfect knowledge of the Father.’ Wonderful this
heresy, not plausible even, but making speculations against Him that
is, that He be not, and everywhere putting forward blasphemy for
reverent language! Were any one, after inquiring into both sides, to be
asked, whether of the two he would follow in faith, or whether of the
two spoke fitly of God,—or rather let them say themselves, these
abettors of irreligion, what, if a man be asked concerning God (for
‘the Word was God’), it were fit to answer That
is, ‘Let them tell us, is it right to predicate this or to
predicate that of God (of one who is God), for such is the Word, viz.
that He was from eternity or was created,’ &c.,
&c.. For from this one question the whole case
on both sides may be determined, what is fitting to say,—He was,
or He was not; always, or before His birth; eternal, or from this and
from then; true, or by adoption, and from participation and in idea κατ᾽
ἐπίνοιαν, vid. Orat. ii. §38.; to call Him one of things originated, or to
unite Him to the Father; to consider Him unlike the Father in essence,
or like and proper to Him; a creature, or Him through whom the
creatures were originated; that He is the Father’s Word, or that
there is another word beside Him, and that by this other He was
originated, and by another wisdom; and that He is only named Wisdom and
Word, and is become a partaker of this wisdom, and second to it?