She was born in Stockton-on-Tees to John McNaughton, a fisherman, and Elizabeth, and she lived with her parents into her 40s. In 1897 as a single mother she had a daughter Alice Hannah McNaughton. In 1907 Sarah married William Wagstaff, a hairdresser, and they lived in Eston, Yorkshire. In 1924 Sarah’s daughter Alice married Arthur William Holder, a carpenter, and by 1927 Sarah had moved south with them to 109 Bognor Road, Whyke, where she died.