Chapter 41.—49. Lastly, he has ended his epistle with an exhortation and warning to
his own party, that they should not be deceived by us, and with a lamentation over those of
our party, that we had made them worse than they had been before. Having therefore
carefully considered and discussed these points, as appears with sufficient clearness from
the words of the epistle which he wrote, Petilianus has made no answer at all to the position
which I advanced to begin with in my epistle, when I asked, Supposing it to be true, as he
asserts, that the conscience of one that gives—or rather, to add what he considers so great
a support to his argument—that the conscience of one that gives in holiness is what we look
for to cleanse the conscience of the recipient, by what means he who receives baptism is to
be cleansed, when, if the conscience of the giver is polluted, it is without the knowledge of
the proposed recipient? Whence it is not surprising that a man resisting in the cause of
falsehood, pressed hard in the straits of the truth that contradicts it, should have chosen
rather to gasp forth mad abuse, than to walk in the path of that truth which cannot be
overcome.
50. And now I would beg of you to pay especial attention to the next few words, that I
may show you clearly what he has been afraid of in not answering this, and that I may bring
into the light what he has endeavored to shroud in obscurity. It certainly was in his power,
when we asked by what means he is to be cleansed, who receives baptism when the conscience
of the giver is polluted without the knowledge of the proposed recipient, to answer with the
greatest ease, From our Lord God; and at any rate to say with the utmost confidence, God
617
wholly cleanses the conscience of the recipient, when he is unacquainted with the stain upon
the conscience of him that gives but not in holiness. But when a man had already been
compelled by the tenets of your sect to rest the cleansing of the recipient on the conscience
of the giver, in that he had said, "For the conscience of him that gives," or "of him that gives
in holiness, is looked for to cleanse the conscience of the recipient," he was naturally afraid
lest any one should seem to be better baptized by a wicked man who concealed his wicked-
ness, than by one that was genuinely and manifestly good; for in the former case his
cleansing would depend not on the conscience of one that gave in holiness, but on the most
excellent holiness of God Himself. With this apprehension, therefore, that he might not be
involved in so great an absurdity, or rather madness, as not to know where he could make
his escape, he was unwilling to say by what means the conscience of the recipient should be
cleansed, when he does not know of the stain upon the conscience of him that gives but not
in holiness; and he thought it better, by making a general confusion with his quarrelsome
uproar, to conceal what was asked of him, than to give a reply to his question, which should
at once discomfit him; never, however, thinking that our letter could be read by men of such
good understanding, or that his would be read by those who had read ours as well, to which
he has professed to make an answer.
Chapter 41
1229
Chapter 41