It
is commonly assumed that the Gallic martyrs favored the Montanists and
exhorted Eleutherus to be mild in his judgment of them, and to preserve
the peace of the Church by permitting them to remain within it and
enjoy fellowship with other Christians. But Salmon (in the Dict. of
Christian Biog. III. p. 937) has shown, in my opinion conclusively,
that the Gallic confessors took the opposite side, and exhorted
Eleutherus to confirm the Eastern Church in its condemnation of the
Montanists, representing to him that he would threaten the peace of the
Church by refusing to recognize the justice of the decision of the
bishops of the East and by setting himself in opposition to them.
Certainly, with their close connection with Asia Minor, we should
expect the Gallic Christians to be early informed of the state of
affairs in the East, and it is not difficult to think that they may
have formed the same opinion in regard to the new prophecy which the
majority of their brethren there had formed. The decisive argument for
Salmon’s opinion is the fact that Eusebius calls the letter of
the Lyons confessors to Eleutherus “pious and most
orthodox.” Certainly, looking upon Montanism as one of the most
execrable of heresies and as the work of Satan himself (cf. his words
in chap. 16, below), it is very difficult to suppose that he can have
spoken of a letter written expressly in favor of the Montanists in any
such terms of respect. Salmon says: “It is monstrous to imagine
that Eusebius, thinking thus of Montanism, could praise as pious or
orthodox the opinion of men who, ignorant of Satan’s devices,
should take the devil’s work for God’s. The way in which we
ourselves read the history is that the Montanists had appealed to
Rome; that the Church party solicited the good offices of their
countrymen settled in Gaul, who wrote to Eleutherus representing the
disturbance to the peace of the churches (a phrase probably preserved
by Eusebius from the letter itself) which would ensue if the Roman
Church should approve what the Church on the spot had
condemned.…To avert, then, the possibility of the calamity of a
breach between the Eastern and Western churches, the Gallic churches,
it would appear, not only wrote, but sent Irenæus to Rome at the
end of 177 or the beginning of 178. The hypothesis here made relieves
us from the necessity of supposing this πρεσβεία to have been unsuccessful, while it fully accounts for the
necessity of sending it.”