The
Fathers entirely misunderstood Marcion, and mistook the significance of
his movement. They regarded it, like Gnosticism in general, solely as a
speculative system, and entirely overlooked its practical aim. The
speculative and theological was not the chief thing with Marcion, but
it is the only thing which receives any attention from his opponents.
His positions, all of which were held only with a practical interest,
were not treated by him in a speculative manner, nor were they handled
logically and systematically. As a consequence, many contradictions
occur in them. These contradictions were felt by his followers, who
laid more and more emphasis upon the speculative over against the
practical; and hence, as Rhodo reports, they fell into disagreement,
and, in their effort to remove the inconsistencies, formed various
schools, differing among themselves according to the element upon which
the greatest weight was laid. There is thus some justification for the
conduct of the Fathers, who naturally carried back and attributed to
Marcion the principles of his followers. But it is our duty to
distinguish the man from his followers, and to recognize his greatness
in spite of their littleness. Not all of them, however, fell completely
away from his practical religious spirit. Apelles, as we shall see
below, was in many respects a worthy follower of his master.