In fact Theodore of Mopsuestia was the first to object
to it, so far as we know, writing as follows: “Mary bare
Jesus, not the Word, for the Word was and remained omnipresent,
although from the beginning he dwelt in Jesus in a peculiar
manner. Thus Mary is properly the Mother of Christ (Christotocos)
but not the mother of God (Theotocos). Only figuratively, per
anaphoram, can she be called Theotocos also, because God was in
Christ in a remarkable manner. Properly she bare a man, in whom
the union with the Word was begun, but was still so little completed,
that he was not yet called the Son of God.” And in another
place he says: “It is madness to say that God is born of
the Virgin.…Not God, but the temple in which God dwelt, is born
of Mary.” I take this passage as
cited by Hefele, Hist. Counc., Vol. III., 9, How far
Theodore had departed from the teaching of the Apostolic days may be
seen by the following quotations from St. Ignatius. “There
is one only physician, of flesh and spirit, generate and ingenerate,
God in man, true Life in death, Son of Mary and of God, first passible
and then impassible, Jesus Christ our Lord.” Ignat., Ad.
Eph., vii. Further on in the same epistle he
says: “For our God, Jesus the Christ, was borne in the womb
by Mary etc.” Ibid.
xviij. With the
first of these passages Bp. Lightfoot very aptly compares the following
from Melito. “Since he was incorporeal, he fashioned a body
for himself of our likeness…he was carried by Mary and clothed by
his Father, he trod the earth and he filled the
heavens.” Melito, Fragm.
14 (ed. Otto); cit. Lightfoot, Apost. Fath., II., 1, p. 48,
n.