What, then, is our doctrine? The
Lord, in delivering the saving Faith to those who become disciples of
the word, joins with the Father and the Son the Holy Spirit also; and
we affirm that the union of that which has once been joined is
continual; for it is not joined in one thing, and separated in others.
But the power of the Spirit, being included with the Father and the Son
in the life-giving power, by which our nature is transferred from the
corruptible life to immortality, and in many other cases also, as in
the conception of “Good,” and “Holy,” and
“Eternal,” “Wise,” “Righteous,”
“Chief,” “Mighty,” and in fact everywhere, has
an inseparable association with them in all the attributes ascribed in
a sense of special excellence. And so we consider that it is right to
think that that which is joined to the Father and the Son in such
sublime and exalted conceptions is not separated from them in any. For
we do not know of any differences by way of superiority and inferiority
in attributes which express our conceptions of the Divine nature, so
that we should suppose it an act of piety (while allowing to the Spirit
community in the inferior attributes) to judge Him unworthy of those
more exalted. For all the Divine attributes, whether named or
conceived, are of like rank one with another, in that they are not
distinguishable in respect of the signification of their subject. For
the appellation of “the Good” does not lead our minds to
one subject, and that of “the Wise,” or “the
Mighty,” or “the Righteous” to another, but the thing
to which all the attributes point is one; and, if you speak of God, you
signify the same Whom you understood by the other attributes. If then
all the attributes ascribed to the Divine nature are of equal force as
regards their designation of the subject, leading our minds to the same
subject in various aspects, what reason is there that one, while
allowing to the Spirit community with the Father and the Son in the
other attributes, should exclude Him from the Godhead alone? It is
absolutely necessary either to allow to Him community in this also, or
not to admit His community in the others. For if He is worthy in the
case of those attributes, He is surely not less worthy in this. But if
He is “less,” according to their phrase Reading with Oehler εἰ δέ
μικρότερον…ἐστὶν, ὥστε…κεχωρίσθαι. The Paris Edit. and the Benedictine S. Basil read
εἰ δὲ
μικρότερον…ἐστὶν, ἢ
ὥστε…χωρῆσαι. “If, according to their phrase, He is too small to be
capable of community,” &c. Oehler’s reading seems to
fit better in the argument. If the new idea of “capacity”
had been introduced at this point, we should expect some other phrase
than μετέχειν
ἄξιον at the end of
the sentence., so that He is excluded from
community with the Father and the Son in the attribute of Godhead,
neither is He worthy to share in any other of the attributes which
belong to God. For the attributes, when rightly understood and mutually
compared by that notion which we contemplate in each case, will be
found to imply nothing less than the appellation of “God.”
And a proof of this is that many even of the inferior existences are
called by this very name. Further, the Divine Scripture is not sparing
in this use of the name even in the case of things incongruous, as when
it names idols by the appellation of God. For it says, “Let the
gods that have not made the heavens and the earth perish, and be cast
down beneath the earth Cf. Jer. x. 11”; and,
“all the gods of the heathen are devils Ps. xcvi. 5 (LXX.).”; and the witch in her incantations,
when she brings up for Saul the spirits that he sought for, says that
she “saw gods 1 Sam. xxviii.
13..” And again
Balaam, being an augur and a seer, and engaging in divination, and
having obtained for himself the instruction of devils and magical
augury, is said in Scripture to receive counsel from God Num. xxii.. One may show by collecting many instances
of the same kind from the Divine Scripture, that this attribute has no
supremacy over the other attributes which are proper to God, seeing
that, as has been said, we find it predicated, in an equivocal sense,
even of things incongruous; but we are nowhere taught in Scripture that
the names of “the Holy,” “the Incorruptible,”
“the Righteous,” “the Good,” are made common to
things unworthy. If, then, they do not deny that the Holy Spirit has
community with the Father and the Son in those attributes which, in
their sense of special excellence, are piously predicated only of the
Divine nature, what reason is there to pretend that He is excluded from
community in this only, wherein it was shown that, by an equivocal use,
even devils and idols share?