Chapter XII.
The difference between matters of precept and of counsel is treated of, as shown in the
case of the young man in the Gospel, and the difference of the rewards set forth both for
counsels and precepts is spoken of.
72. Marriage, then, is honourable, but chastity is more honourable, for “he that giveth
his virgin in marriage doeth well, but he that giveth her not in marriage doeth better.”2600
That, then, which is good need not be avoided, but that which is better should be chosen.
And so it is not laid upon any, but set before him. And, therefore, the Apostle said well:
“Concerning virgins I have no commandment of the Lord, yet I give my counsel.”2601 For
a command is issued to those subject, counsel is given to friends. Where there is a command-
ment, there is a law; where counsel, there is grace. A commandment is given to enforce what
is according to nature, a counsel to incite us to follow grace. And, therefore, the Law was
given to the Jews, but grace was reserved for the elect. The Law was given that, through fear
of punishment, it might recall those who were wandering beyond the limits of nature, to
their observance, but grace to incite the elect both by the desire of good things, and also by
the promised rewards.
73. You will see the difference between precept and counsel, if you remember the case
of him in the Gospel, to whom it is first commanded to do no murder, not to commit
adultery, not to bear false witness; for that is a commandment which has a penalty for its
transgression. But when he said that he had fulfilled all the commandments of the Law,
there is given to him a counsel that he should sell all that he had and follow the Lord,2602
for these things are not imposed as commands, but are offered as counsels. For there are
two ways of commanding things, one by way of precept, the other by way of counsel. And
so the Lord in one way says: “Thou shalt not kill,” where He gives a commandment; in the
other He says: “If thou wilt be perfect, sell all that thou hast.” He is, then, not bound by a
commandment to whom the choice is left.
74. And so they who have fulfilled the commandments are able to say: “We are unprof-
itable servants, we have done that which was our duty to do.”2603 The virgin does not say
404
this, nor he who sold all his goods, but they rather await the stored-up rewards like the holy
Apostle who says: “Behold we have forsaken all and followed Thee, what shall we have
therefore?”2604 He says not, like the unprofitable servant, that he has done that which was
his duty to do, but as being profitable to his Master, because he has multiplied the talents
2600 1 Cor. vii. 28.
2601 1 Cor. vii. 25.
2602 S. Matt. xix. 18–21.
2603 S. Luke xvii. 10.
2604 S. Matt. xix. 27.
Chapter XII. The difference between matters of precept and of counsel is treated of, as shown in the case of the young man in the Gospel, and the difference of the rewards set forth both for counsels and precepts is spoken of.
876
Chapter XII. The difference between matters of precept and of counsel is…