Would not the defenders of the
opposite belief say this: that the body, being composite, must
necessarily be resolved into that of which it is composed? And when the
coalition of elements in the body ceases, each of those elements
naturally gravitates towards its kindred element with the irresistible
bias of like to like; the heat in us will thus unite with heat, the
earthy with the solid, and each of the other elements also will pass
towards its like. Where, then, will the soul be after that? If one
affirm that it is in those elements, one will be obliged to admit that
it is identical with them, for this fusion could not possibly take
place between two things of different natures. But this being granted,
the soul must necessarily be viewed as a complex thing, fused as it is
with qualities so opposite. But the complex is not simple, but must be
classed with the composite, and the composite is necessarily
dissoluble; and dissolution means the destruction of the compound; and the
destructible is not immortal, else the flesh itself, resolvable as it
is into its constituent elements, might so be called immortal. If, on
the other hand, the soul is something other than these elements, where
can our reason suggest a place for it to be, when it is thus, by virtue
of its alien nature, not to be discovered in those elements, and there
is no other place in the world, either, where it may continue, in
harmony with its own peculiar character, to exist? But, if a thing can
be found nowhere, plainly it has no existence.