21. Proceed we then to consider the attributes of
the Father, and we shall come to know whether this Image is really His.
The Father is eternal, immortal, powerful, light, King, Sovereign, God,
Lord, Creator, and Maker. These attributes must be in the Image, to
make it true that he ‘that hath seen’ the Son ‘hath
seen the Father John xiv. 9..’ If the Son
be not all this, but, as the Arians consider, originate, and not
eternal, this is not a true Image of the Father, unless indeed they
give up shame, and go on to say, that the title of Image, given to the
Son, is not a token of a similar essence ὁμοίας
οὐσίας. And so
§20 init. ὅμοιον
κατ᾽
οὐσίαν,
and ὅμοιος τῆς
οὐσίας,
§26. ὅμοιος
κατ᾽
οὐσίαν, iii.
26. and ὅμοιος κατὰ
τὴν οὐσίαν
τοῦ πατρός. Ep. Æg. 17. Also Alex. Ep. Encycl. 2.
Considering what he says in the de Syn. §38, &c., in
controversy with the semi-Arians a year or two later, this use of their
formula, in preference to the ὁμοούσιον (vid. foregoing note), deserves our attention.,
but His name De
Decr. §16. only. But this, on the other hand, O
ye enemies of Christ, is not an Image, nor is it an Expression. For
what is the likeness of what is out of nothing to Him who brought what
was nothing into being? or how can that which is not, be like Him that
is, being short of Him in once not being, and in its having its place
among things originate? However, such the Arians wishing Him to be,
devised for themselves arguments such as this;—‘If the Son
is the Father’s offspring and Image, and is like in all things De
Syn. 27 (5) note 1, and infr. §40. to the Father, then it necessarily holds that as He is begotten, so He
begets, and He too becomes father of a son. And again, he who is
begotten from Him, begets in his turn, and so on without limit; for
this is to make the Begotten like Him that begat Him.’ Authors of
blasphemy, verily, are these foes of God! who, sooner than confess that
the Son is the Father’s Image The
objection is this, that, if our Lord be the Father’s Image, He
ought to resemble Him in being a Father. S. Athanasius answers that God
is not as man; with us a son becomes a father because our nature
is ῥευστὴ,
transitive and without stay, ever shifting and passing on into new
forms and relations; but that God is perfect and ever the same, what He
is once that He continues to be; God the Father remains Father, and God
the Son remains Son. Moreover men become fathers by detachment and
transmission, and what is received is handed on in a succession;
whereas the Father, by imparting Himself wholly, begets the Son: and a
perfect nativity finds its termination in itself. The Son has not a
Son, because the Father has not a Father. Thus the Father is the only
true Father, and the Son alone true Son; the Father only a Father, the
Son only a Son; being really in their Persons what human fathers are
but by office, character, accident, and name; vid. De Decr. 11,
note 6. And since the Father is unchangeable as Father, in nothing does
the Son more fulfil the idea of a perfect Image than in being
unchangeable too. Thus S. Cyril also, Thesaur. 10. p. 124. And
this perhaps may illustrate a strong and almost startling implication
of some of the Greek Fathers, that the First Person in the Holy
Trinity, is not God [in virtue of His Fatherhood]. E.g.
εἰ δὲ
θεὸς ὁ υἱ& 232·ς,
οὐκ ἐπεὶ υἱ&
231·ς· ὁμοίως
καὶ ὁ πατὴρ,
οὐκ ἐπεὶ
πατὴρ, θεός·
ἀλλ᾽ ἐπεὶ
οὐσία τοιάδε,
εἷς ἐστὶ
πατὴρ καὶ ὁ
υἱ& 232·ς
θεός. Nyssen. t. i.
p. 915. vid. Petav. de Deo i. 9. §13. Should it be asked,
‘What is the Father if not God?’ it is enough to answer,
‘the Father.’ Men differ from each other as being
individuals, but the characteristic difference between Father and Son
is, not that they are individuals, but that they are Father and
Son. In these extreme statements it must be ever borne in mind that we
are contemplating divine things according to our notions. not in
fact: i.e. speaking of the Almighty Father, as such;
there being no real separation between His Person and His Substance. It
may be added, that, though theologians differ in their decisions, it
would appear that our Lord is not the Image of the Father’s
person, but of the Father’s substance; in other words, not of the
Father considered as Father, but considered as God. That is, God the
Son is like and equal to God the Father, because they are both the same
God. De Syn. 49. note 4, also next note., conceive
material and earthly ideas concerning the Father Himself, ascribing to
Him severings and Ep. Eus. 7, de Decr. 11, note 8. effluences and
influences. If then God be as man, let Him become also a parent as man,
so that His Son should be father of another, and so in succession one
from another, till the series they imagine grows into a multitude of
gods. But if God be not as man, as He is not, we must not impute to Him
the attributes of man. For brutes and men, after a Creator has begun
them, are begotten by succession; and the son, having been begotten of
a father who was a son, becomes accordingly in his turn a father to a
son, in inheriting from his father that by which he himself has come to
be. Hence in such instances there is not, properly speaking, either
father or son, nor do the father and the son stay in their respective
characters, for the son himself becomes a father, being son of his
father, but father of his son. But it is not so in the Godhead; for not
as man is God; for the Father is not from a father; therefore doth He
not beget one who shall become a father; nor is the Son from effluence
of the Father, nor is He begotten from a father that was begotten;
therefore neither is He begotten so as to beget. Thus it belongs to the
Godhead alone, that the Father is properly κυρίως,
de Decr. 11, note 6. Elsewhere Athan. says, ‘The Father
being one and only is Father of a Son one and only; and in the instance
of Godhead only have the names Father and Son stay, and are ever; for
of men if any one be called father, yet he has been son of another; and
if he be called son, yet is he called father of another; so that in the
case of men the names father and son do not properly, κυρίως, hold.’ ad Serap. i. 16. also ibid. iv. 4 fin.
and 6. vid. also κυρίως,
Greg. Naz. Orat. 29. 5. ἀληθῶς,
Orat. 25, 16. ὄντως, Basil. contr.
Eunom. i. 5. p. 215.
father, and the Son properly son, and in Them, and Them only, does it
hold that the Father is ever Father and the Son ever Son.