Now as to his orthodoxy, so far as his extant writings are concerned, I think any scholar,
not anxious to make out a case, will abide by the candid judgment of Bull, who defends his
reputation against Petavius.5004 “By no means,” he says, “should we tolerate that injustice
of the Jesuit Petau towards the ancient writers, against their manifest mind and purpose;
twisting, as he everywhere does, their sound and Catholic sayings into a sense alien and
heretical.”
The work upon the Trinity, which is a most valuable contribution to ante-Nicene
theology, is said by Cave to have been written about a.d. 257; and that upon the Jewish meats
608
seems to have been composed during the Decian persecution. His heresy, such as it was,
turned upon unrelenting discipline, and was a sin against charity, which is greater than faith
itself. It violated the “seventy times seven” maxim of our Lord, and the comprehensive
precept, “Forgive, and ye shall be forgiven.” It wounded Christian unity at a perilous period,
and when every breach in the wall of the fold was sure to let in the wolves.
“He may have aspired to the papal chair,” says a contemporary writer5005 of no mean
repute, adding, “to which he had the best claim.” Then he says, “Novatian was elected anti-
pope by a minority, and consecrated by three Italian bishops.” Is this history? What impres-
sion must it give to the young student? The learned writer whom I quote shows clearly
enough that there was no “papacy” in primitive times, as that word is universally understood.
Why, then, put a face upon Antiquity so utterly misleading? Neither Novatian, nor his
consecrators, nor Cornelius, against whom he rebelled, ever dreamed of anything more than
of an episcopal chair; venerable, indeed, for its succession of pastors from the times of SS.
Peter and Paul, but as yet hardly felt in the Christian brotherhood; which for two centuries
had produced many pious but few eminent men, and in which Novatian himself was the
earliest contributor to the “Latin Christianity,” already founded and flourishing, not in Italy,
but in Northern Africa.
The following is the Introductory Notice of the Edinburgh translator, the Rev. Dr.
Wallis, who, I am glad to observe, is tender towards our author’s memory:—
The biography of Novatian belongs to the ecclesiastical history of the third century. He
was, or is reputed to have been, the founder of a sect which claimed for itself the name of
“Puritan”5006 (καθαροί). For a long time he was in determined opposition to Cornelius,
bishop of Rome, in regard to the admission of the lapsed and penitent into the Church; but
the facts of the controversy and much of our information in regard to Novatian are to be
got only from his enemies, the Roman bishop and his adherents. Accordingly, some have
5004 Defensio Fid. Nicæn., Works, vol. v. p. 374.
5005 Dr. Schaff; History of Christian Church, vol. ii. p. 851.
5006 [This is again putting a false face upon Antiquity. Purists, rather; i.e., in morals.]
1442
Introductory Notice to Novatian, a Roman Presbyter.