of God was begotten, and that he was not produced like all creatures. We know that the
Arians very commonly applied the word “begotten” to Christ, using it in such cases as syn-
onymous with “created,” and thus not implying, as the Athanasians did when they used the
word, that he was of one substance with the Father (compare, for instance, the explanation
of the meaning of the term given by Eusebius of Nicomedia in his epistle to Paulinus; Theod.
H. E. I. 6). It is evident that the use of this word had deceived our Eusebius, and that he was
led by it to think that they taught that the Son was of the Father in a peculiar sense, and did
in reality partake in some way of essential Godhood. And indeed it is not at all surprising
that the words of Arius, in his epistle to Alexander of Alexandria (see Athan. Ep. de conc.
Arim. et Seleuc., chap. II. §3; Oxford edition of Athanasius’ Tracts against Arianism, p. 97),
quoted by Eusebius in his epistle to the same Alexander, should give Eusebius that impression.
The words are as follows: “The God of the law, and of the prophets, and of the New Testament
before eternal ages begat an only-begotten Son, through whom also He made the ages and
the universe. And He begat him not in appearance, but in truth, and subjected him to his
own will, unchangeable and immutable, a perfect creature of God, but not as one of the
creatures.” Arius’ use here of the word “begat,” and his qualification of the word “creature”
by the adjective “perfect,” and by the statement that he was “not as one of the creatures”
naturally tended to make Eusebius think that Arius acknowledged a real divinity of the Son,
and that appeared to him to be all that was necessary. Meanwhile Alexander in his epistle
to Alexander of Constantinople (Theod. H. E. I. 4) had, as Eusebius says, misstated Arius’
opinion, or at least had attributed to him the belief that Christ was “made like all other men
that have ever been born,” whereas Arius expressly disclaims such a belief. Alexander un-
doubtedly thought that that was the legitimate result to which the other views of Arius must
lead; but Eusebius did not think so, and felt himself called upon to remonstrate with Alex-
ander for what seemed to him the latter’s unfairness in the matter.
When we examine the Cæsarean creed2 which Eusebius presented to the Council as a
fair statement of his belief, we find nothing in it inconsistent with the acceptance of the kind
of Arianism which he defends in his epistle to Alexander, and which he evidently supposed
to be practically the Arianism of Arius himself. In his epistle to Euphration, however, Euse-
bius seems at first glance to go further and to give up the real divinity of the Son. His words
are, “Since the Son is himself God, but not true God.” But we have no right to interpret these
words, torn as they are from the context which might make their meaning perfectly plain,
without due regard to Eusebius’ belief expressed elsewhere in this epistle, and in his epistle
to Alexander which was evidently written about the same time. In the epistle to Alexander
he clearly reveals a belief in the real divinity of the Son, while in the other fragment of his
2 For a translation of the creed see below, p. 16, where it is given as a part of Eusebius’ epistle to the Church
of Cæsarea.
25
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.