Eusebius here identifies the census mentioned by Josephus
(Ant. XVIII. 1. 1) and referred to in Acts v. 37, with the one
mentioned in Luke ii. 2; but this is an obvious
error, as an interval of ten years separated the two. Valesius
considers it all one census, and hence regards Eusebius as correct in
his statement; but this is very improbable. Jachmann (in Illgen’s
Zeitschrift f. hist. Theologie, 1839, II. p. 35 sq.), according
to his custom, charges Eusebius with willful deception and perversion
of the facts. But such a charge is utterly without warrant. Eusebius,
in cases where we can control his statements, can be shown to have been
always conscientious. Moreover, in his Chron. (ed. Schoene II.
p. 144) he identifies the two censuses in the same way. But his
Chronicles were written some years before his History,
and he cannot have had any object to deceive in them such as Jachmann
assumes that he had in his History. It is plain that Eusebius
has simply made a blunder, a thing not at all surprising when we
remember how frequent his chronological errors are. He is guilty of an
inexcusable piece of carelessness, but nothing worse. It was natural to
connect the two censuses mentioned as taking place under the same
governor, though a little closer attention to the facts would have
shown him the discrepancy in date, which he simply
overlooked.