Thus far our argument goes with
him. But the riddle with which he accompanies his words we must leave
to those trained in the wisdom of Prunicus This
may mean “short-hand” i.e. something difficult to
decipher. See Book I. vi. note 10. to
interpret: for he seems to have produced what he has said from that
system. “Being incorruptible without beginning, He is ungenerate
without end, being so called absolutely, and independently of aught
beside Himself.” Now whoever has purged ears and an enlightened
understanding knows, even without my saying it, that beyond the jingle
of words produced by their extraordinary combination, there is no trace
of sense in what he says; and if any shadow of an idea could be found
in such a din of words, it would prove to be either profane or
ridiculous. For what do you mean when you say that He is without
beginning as being without end, and without end as being without
beginning? Do you think beginning identical with end, and that the two
words are employed in the same sense, just as the appellations Simon
and Peter represent one and the same subject, and on this account, in
accordance with your thinking beginning and end the same, did you,
combining under one signification these two words which denote
privation of each other,—end, I mean, and beginning,—and
taking the being without end as convertible with the being without end,
blend and confound one word with the other; and is this the meaning of
such a mixing up of words, when you say that He is ungenerate as being
without end, and that He is without end as being ungenerate? Yet how is
it that you did not see the profanity as well as the ridiculous folly
of your words? For if by this novel confusion of the words they are
made convertible, so that ungenerate means ungenerate without end, and
that which is without end is such ungenerately, it follows by necessity
that that which is without end must needs be so as being ungenerate:
and thus it comes to pass, my good friend, that your much-talked-of
ungeneracy, which you say is the only characteristic of the
Father’s essence, will be found to be shared with whatever is
immortal, and to be making all things consubstantial with the Father,
because it is alike apparent in all things whose life, by reason of
their immortality, goes on to infinity, archangels, that is, angels,
human souls, and, it may be also, in the Apostate host, the Devil and
his dæmons. For if that which is without end, and imperishable,
must also by your argument be ungenerately imperishable, then in
whatsoever is without end and imperishable there must be connoted
ungeneracy. These are the absurdities into which those men fall who,
before they have learnt what it is fitting for them to learn, only
publish their own ignorance by what they attempt to teach. For if he
had any faculty of discernment, he would not be ignorant of the
peculiar sense inherent in his terms, “without beginning,”
and “without end,” and that the term without end is common
to all things whose life we believe capable of extension to infinity,
while the term without beginning belongs to Him alone Who is without
originating cause. How, then, is it possible for us to regard that
which is common to them all, as equivalent to that which is believed by
all to be a special attribute of the Deity alone, so that we thereby
either extend ungeneracy to everything that shares in immortality, or
else must not allow immortality to any one of them, seeing that the
being without end is to belong only to the ungenerate, and vice versa,
the being ungenerate is to belong only to that which is without end?
Thus everything without end would have to be regarded as
ungenerate.