The agreement of the three documents is most
striking, and the more so since the chronicles are clearly independent
both of one another and especially of the letter of Ammon, as is clear
from the fact that neither mentions the φήμη, while the Festal Index
implicitly contradicts it. This appears to be a crucial case in many
ways. Firstly, the three narratives are all consistent in
excluding the possibility of any such council as is supposed to have
been summoned (see above, p. lx.). Against this there is nothing but
the hasty inference of Thdt. (corrected by Valois, see above,
ib.); the valueless testimony of the Libellus Synodicus
(9th cent.); the marvellous tale of Sozom. v. 7 (referred to this time
by Tillem. viii. 219, but by Soz. to the death of George: probably an
amplification of Hist. Aceph. ‘visus est’) that
Athanasius suddenly to the delight of his people was found enthroned in
his Church; and the more vague statement of Socr. (iii. 24) that he
regained his church ‘at once after Julian’s death.’
As the three fifth-century writers are implicitly contradicted by three
writers of Alexandria at the end of the previous century, the latter
must be believed against the former. Secondly, the Index,
the later as it appears, of the two chronicles, would seem to represent
a form of the story less marvellous and therefore earlier than that of
the Narratio. Now the latter certainly belongs to the Episcopate
of Theophilus. The Index therefore can scarcely be placed later,
and the Hist. Aceph. would fall, as Sievers, Einl. 2, had
independently placed it at the beginning of the Episcopate of
Theophilus. Thirdly, we have here an excellent example not only
of the value of the combined evidence of the two chronicles, but
also of their character as representing in many important respects the
Alexandrian tradition of the last third of the fourth century. Before
leaving this question it will be well to consider the dates a little
more closely. Hierapolis was counted eight days’ journey from
Antioch. From Alexandria to Antioch by sea was about 500 miles, i.e.
with a fair wind scarcely more than four days’ sail (it might be
less, cf. Conybeare and Howson, St. Paul, vol. 2, p. 376,
sq. ed. 1877). This allows
about twelve days for Athan. to reach the Euphrates from Alexandria,
remembering that southerly winds prevail in the Eastern Mediterranean
at this season (Sievers, Einl. 28). Now Athan. reached
Hierapolis on Sept. 6 (Thoth 8, Egyptian leap-year). But according to
the Index, he reached Alex. after Julian’s death was
published, and this according to Hist. Aceph. was on Mesori 26,
i.e. Aug. 19. From that day to Sept. 6 are eighteen days, leaving about
a week’s margin for Ath. to hear the news, reach Alexandria, and
perhaps for delay in finding a vessel, &c. But a far wider margin
is really available, for the official announcement must have been
preceded by many rumours, and was probably not despatched till more
than a fortnight after Julian’s death (as is observed by Mr.
Gwatkin, p. 221). If we remember that Athanasius, according to the
Letter of Ammon, was making all possible haste (supra, §9)
we shall again realise the subtle cohesion of these three sources, and
the impossibility of the ‘large Synod’ imagined by some
historians for the year 363.