The secularization of monasteries was an evil which grew
with their wealth and influence. At a Council held by the
patriarch Photius in the Apostles’ church at Constantinople, it
is complained that some persons attach the name of
“monastery” to property of their own, and while professing
to dedicate it to God, write themselves down as lords of what has been
thus consecrated, and are not ashamed to claim after such consecration
the same power over it which they had before. In the West, we
find this abuse attracting the attention of Gregory the Great, who
writes to a bishop that “rationalis ordo” would not allow a
layman to pervert a monastic foundation at will to his own uses
(Epist. viii., 31). In ancient Scotland, the occasional
dispersion of religious communities, and, still more, the
clan-principle which assigned chieftain-rights over monasteries to the
descendants of the founder, left at Dunkeld, Brechin, Abernethy, and
elsewhere, “nothing but the mere name of abbacy applied to the
lands, and of abbot borne by the secular lord for the time”
(Skene’s Celtic Scotland, ii., 365; cf.
Anderson’s Scotland in Early Christian Times, p.
235). So, after the great Irish monastery of Bangor in Down was
destroyed by the Northmen, “non defuit,” says St. Bernard,
“qui illud teneret cure possessionibus suis; nam et
constituebantur per electionem etiam, et abbates appellabantur,
servantes nomine, etsi non re, quod olim exstiterat” (De Vita
S. Malachiæ, vj.). So in 1188 Giraldus Cambrensis found
a lay abbot in possession of the venerable church of Llanbadarn Vawr; a
“bad custom,” he says,
“had grown up, whereby powerful laymen, at first chosen by the
clergy to be “œconomi” or “patroni et
defensores,” had usurped “totum jus,” appropriated
the lands, and left to the clergy nothing but the altars, with tithes
and offerings (Itin. Camb. ii., 4). This abuse must be
distinguished from the corrupt device whereby, in Bede’s later
years, Northumbrian nobles contrived to gain for their estates the
immunities of abbey-lands by professing to found monasteries, which
they filled with disorderly monks, who lived there in contempt of all
rule (Bede, Ep. to Egbert, vij.). In the year of his
birth, the first English synod had forbidden bishops to despoil
consecrated monasteries (Bede, iv., 5).