10. You write in your letter that, before Paulinianus
was made a presbyter, the pope Epiphanius never took you to task in
connection with Origen’s errors. To begin with, this is doubtful,
and I have to consider which of the two men I should believe. He says
that he did object, you deny it; he brings forward witnesses, you will
not listen to them when they are produced; he even relates that This probably
relates to Rufinus, whose name was mentioned by Epiphanius in his
letter to John.another besides yourself was arraigned by
him: you refuse to admit this in the case of either; he sends a letter
to you by one of his clergy, and demands an answer: you are silent,
dare not open your lips, and, challenged in Palestine, speak at
Alexandria. Which of you is to be believed is not for me to say. I
suppose that you yourself would not, in the face of so distinguished a
man, venture to claim truth for yourself, and impute falsehood to him.
But it is possible that each speaks from his own point of view. I will
call a witness against you, and that witness is yourself. For if there
were no dispute about doctrines, if you had not roused the anger of an
old man, if he had given you no reply, what need was there for you, who
do not excel in gifts of speech, to discuss in a single sermon in the
church the whole circle of doctrine—the Trinity, the assumption
of our Lord’s body, the cross, hell, the nature of angels, the
condition of souls, the Saviour’s resurrection and our own, and
this as taking place on this earth (topics perhaps omitted in your
manuscript) in the presence of the masses, in the presence, too, of a
man of such distinction? and to speak with such perfect assurance and
to gallop through it all without stopping to draw breath? What shall we
say of the ancient writers of the Church, who were scarce able to
explain single difficulties in many volumes? What of the vessel of
election, the Gospel trumpet, the
roaring of our lion, the thunderer of the Gentiles, the river of
Christian eloquence, who, when confronted by the Col. i. 26.mystery concealed from ages and
generations, and by Rom. xi. 33.the depth of
the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God, rather marvels at it
than discusses it? What of Isaiah, who pointed beforehand to the
Virgin? That single thing was too much for him, and he says, Is. liii. 8.“Who shall declare his
generation?” In our age a poor mannikin has been found, who, with
one turn of the tongue, and a brilliancy exceeding that of the sun,
discourses on all ecclesiastical questions. If no one asked you for the
display, and everything was quiet, you were foolish to enter
voluntarily upon so hazardous a discussion. If, on the other hand, the
object of your speaking was the satisfaction you owed to the faith, it
follows that the cause of strife was not the ordination of a Paulinianus.priest, who, it is certain, was ordained
long after. You have deceived only those who were not on the spot, and
your letters flatter the ears of strangers only.