those children who were slain when Herod sought our Lord Jesus Christ to put Him to
death.”2735
19. These things I wrote at that time when I was endeavouring to defend the opinion
which is now under discussion. For, as I mentioned shortly before, I was labouring to prove
that whichever of these four opinions regarding the soul’s incarnation may be found true,
the substance of the Creator is absolutely free from blame, and is completely removed from
all share in our sins. And, therefore, whichever of these opinions might come to be established
or demolished by the truth, this had no bearing on the object aimed at in the work which I
was then attempting, seeing that whichever opinion might win the victory over all the rest,
after they had been examined in a more thorough discussion, this would take place without
causing me any disquietude, because my object then was to prove that, even admitting all
these opinions, the doctrine maintained by me remained unshaken. But now my object is,
by the force of sound reasoning, to select, if possible, one opinion out of the four; and,
therefore, when I carefully consider the words now quoted from that book, I do not see that
the arguments there used in defending the opinion which we are now discussing are valid
and conclusive.
20. For what may be called the chief prop of my defence is in the sentence, “Moreover,
who knows what may be given to the little children, by means of whose sufferings the parents
530
have their obdurate hearts subdued, or their faith exercised, or their compassion proved?
Who knows what good recompense God may, in the secret of His judgments, reserve for
these little ones?” I see that this is not an unwarranted conjecture in the case of infants who,
in any way, suffer (though they know it not) for the sake of Christ and in the cause of true
religion, and of infants who have already been made partakers of the sacrament of Christ;
because, apart from union to the one Mediator, they cannot be delivered from condemnation,
and so put in a position in which it is even possible that a recompense could be made to
them for the evils which, in diverse afflictions, they have endured in this world. But since
the question cannot be fully solved, unless the answer include also the case of those who,
without having received the sacrament of Christian fellowship, die in infancy after enduring
the most painful sufferings, what recompense can be conceived of in their case, seeing that,
besides all that they suffer in this life, perdition awaits them in the life to come? As to the
baptism of infants, I have, in the same book, given an answer, not, indeed, fully, but so far
as seemed necessary for the work which then occupied me, proving that it profits children,
even though they do not know what it is, and have, as yet, no faith of their own; but on the
subject of the perdition of those infants who depart from this life without baptism, I did not
think it necessary to say anything then, because the question under discussion was different
from that with which we are now engaged.
2735 De libero Arbitrio, lib. iii. ch. 23. n. 67.
1126
To Jerome