and the well-digger both move their hands: the mining of the earth, the murder of a man
are results of the motion of the hands. The soldier slays the foe, and the husbandman wields
the fork which breaks the clod, with his hands. How, then, can this doctrinaire lay it down
that the ‘same energies produce sameness of work?’ But even if we were to grant that this
72
view of his had any truth in it, the essential union of the Son with the Father, and of the
Holy Spirit with the Son, is yet again more fully proved. For if there existed any variation
in their energies, so that the Son worked His will in a different manner to the Father, then
(on the above supposition) it would be fair to conjecture, from this variation, a variation
also in the beings which were the result of these varying energies. But if it is true that the
manner of the Father’s working is likewise the manner always of the Son’s, both from our
Lord’s own words and from what we should have expected a priori—(for the one is not
unbodied while the other is embodied, the one is not from this material, the other from that,
the one does not work his will in this time and place, the other in that time and place, nor
is there difference of organs in them producing difference of result, but the sole movement
of their wish and of their will is sufficient, seconded in the founding of the universe by the
power that can create anything)—if, I say, it is true that in all respects the Father from Whom
are all things, and the Son by Whom are all things in the actual form of their operation work
alike, then how can this man hope to prove the essential difference between the Son and the
Holy Ghost by any difference and separation between the working of the Son and the
Father? The very opposite, as we have just seen, is proved to be the case157; seeing that there
is no manner of difference contemplated between the working of the Father and that of the
Son; and so that there is no gulf whatever between the being of the Son and the being of the
Spirit, is shewn by the identity of the power which gives them their subsistence; and our
pamphleteer himself confirms this; for these are his words verbatim: “the same energies
producing sameness of works.” If sameness of works is really produced by likeness of energies,
and if (as they say) the Son is the work of the Father and the Spirit the work of the Son, the
likeness in manner158 of the Father’s and the Son’s energies will demonstrate the sameness
of these beings who each result from them.
But he adds, “variation in the works indicates variation in the energies.” How, again, is
this dictum of his corroborated by facts? Look, if you please, at plain instances. Is not the
‘energy’ of command, in Him who embodied the world and all things therein by His sole
will, a single energy? “He spake and they were made. He commanded and they were created.”
Was not the thing commanded in every case alike given existence: did not His single will
suffice to give subsistence to the nonexistent? How, then, when such vast differences are
157 Punctuating παρασκευάζεται, ἐπείδὴ, κ.τ.λ. instead of a full stop, as Oehler.
158 Gregory replaces ‘sameness’ (in the case of the energies in Eunomius argument) by ‘likeness’ since the
Father and the Son could not be said to be the same, and their energies, therefore, are not identical but similar.
136
He falsely imagines that the same energies produce the same works, and that…