SECT. V.
Objections, that this scheme of Necessity renders all Means and Endeavours for avoiding
Sin, or obtaining Virtue and Holiness, vain, and to no purpose; and that it makes men no
more than mere machines, in affairs of morality and religion, answered.
Arminians say, If sin and virtue come to pass by a Necessity consisting in a sure connexion
of causes and effects, antecedents and consequents, it can never be worth while to use any
Means or Endeavours to obtain the one, and avoid the other; seeing no Endeavours can alter
the futurity of the event, which is become necessary by a connexion already established.
But I desire, that this matter may be fully considered; and that it may be examined with
a thorough strictness, whether it will follow that Endeavours and Means, in order to avoid
or obtain any future thing, must be more in vain, on the supposition of such a connexion
of antecedents and consequents, than if the contrary be supposed.
For Endeavours to be in vain, is for them not to be successful; that is to say, for them
not eventually to be the Means of the thing aimed at, which cannot be, but in one of these
two ways; either, first, That although the Means are used, yet the event aimed at does not
follow; or, secondly, If the event does follow, it is not because of the Means, or from any
connexion or dependence of the event on the Means, the event would have come to pass as
well without the Means as with them. If either of these two things are the case, then the
Means are not properly successful, and are truly in vain. The success or non-success of
Means, in order to an effect, or their being in vain or not in vain, consists in those Means
being connected, or not connected, with the effect, in such a manner as this, viz. That the
effect is with the Means, and not without them; or. that the being of the effect is, on the one
hand, connected with Means, and the want of the effect, on the other hand, is connected
with the want of the Means. If there be such a connexion as this between Means and end,
the Means are not in vain: the more there is of such a connexion, the further they are from
being in vain; and the less of such a connexion, the more they are in vain.
Now, therefore, the question to be answered—in order to determine, whether it follows
from this doctrine of the necessary connexion between foregoing things, and consequent
ones, that Means used in order to any effect, are more in vain than they would be other-
wise—is, whether it follows from it, that there is less of the forementioned connexion between
Means and effect; that is, whether on the supposition of there being a real and true connexion
between antecedent things and consequent ones, there must be less of a connexion between
Means and effect, than on the supposition of there being no fixed connexion between
antecedent things and consequent ones: and the very stating of this question is sufficient to
answer it. It must appear to every one that will open his eyes, that this question cannot be
affirmed, without the grossest absurdity and inconsistence. Means are foregoing things, and
effects are following things: And if there were no connexion between foregoing things and
following ones, there could be no connexion between Means and end; and so all Means
SECTION V. Objections, that this scheme of Necessity renders all Means and Endeavours for avoiding Sin, or obtaining Virtue and Holiness, vain, and to no purpose; and that it makes men no more than mere machines, in affairs of morality and religion, answered.
701
SECTION V. Objections, that this scheme of Necessity renders all Means…