Excursus on the Council of Frankfort, a.d. 794.
It has been commonly represented that the Council of Frankfort, which was a large
Synod of the West, with legates of the Pope present and composed of the bishops of Gaul,
584
Germany, and Aquitaine, devoted its attention to a consideration of the question of the ven
eration due to images and of the claims of the Second Council of Nice to being an Ecumen-
ical Synod. I do not know upon what grounds such statements have rested, but certainly
not upon anything revealed by any remains of the council we possess, for among these we
find but one brief paragraph upon the subject, to wit, the Second Canon, which reads as
follows (Labbe and Cossart, Concilia, Tom. vii, col. 1057):
“II. The question was brought forward concerning the recent synod which the Greeks
had held at Constantinople concerning the adoration of images, that all should be judged
as worthy of anathema who did not pay to the images of the Saints service and adoration
as to the Divine Trinity. Our most holy fathers rejected with scorn and in every way such
adoration and service, and unanimously condemned it.”
Now in the first place I call the reader’s attention to the fact that the Conciliabulum of
754 was held at Constantinople but that the Seventh Council was held at Nice. It would
seem as if the two had got mixed in the mind of the writer.553
In the second place neither of these synods, nor any other synod, decreed that the “ser-
vice” (λατρεία) and “adoration” (προσκύνησις) due to the holy Trinity was under pain of
anathema to be given to “the images of the Saints.”
On this second canon Hefele writes as follows:
(Hefele. Concil., § 398).
The second of these canons deserves our full attention; in it, as we have seen, the Synod
of Frankfort expresses its feeling against the Second Ecumenical Council of Nice, and against
the veneration of images; Eginhard also gives us the information that it took this action,
viz.: “for it was decided by all [i.e. at Frankfort] that the synod, which a few years before
was gathered together in Constantinople (sic) under Irene and her son Constantine, and is
called by them not only the Seventh but also Ecumenical, should neither be held nor declared
to be the Seventh nor ecumenical but wholly without authority.”
Hefele rejects the views of Baronius, Bellarmine, Surius, and Binius. I have no intention
of defending the position of any one of these writers but I translate Binius’s note, merely
remarking that it is easier to reject his conclusion than to answer the arguments upon which
it rests.
(Severinus Binius, Labbe and Cossart, Concilia, Tom. VII., col. 1070.)
553 This has been explained by saying that the last meeting was in the palace at Constantinople.
Excursus on the Council of Frankfort, A.D. 794.
1075
Excursus on the Council of Frankfort, A.D. 794.