So far, we have especially had in view those minor treatises of S. Gregory which illustrate
such variations from Athanasian modes of expression as are to be found in the writers of
the “Neo-Nicene” school. These are perhaps his most characteristic works upon the subject.
But the doctrine of the Trinity, as he held it, is further set forth and enforced in other
treatises which are, from another point of view, much more important than those with
which we have been dealing—in his Oratio Catechetica, and his more directly polemical
treatises against Eunomius. In both these sections of his writings, when allowance is made
for the difference of terminology already discussed, we are less struck by the divergencies
from S. Athanasius’ presentment of the doctrine than by the substantial identity of S.
Gregory’s reasoning with that of S. Athanasius, as the latter is displayed, for example, in the
“Orations against the Arians.”
There are, of course, many points in which S. Gregory falls short of his great predecessor;
but of these some may perhaps be accounted for by the different aspect of the Arian contro-
versy as it presented itself to the two champions of the Faith. The later school of Arianism
may indeed be regarded as a perfectly legitimate and rigidly logical development of the
doctrines taught by Arius himself; but in some ways the task of S. Gregory was a different
task from that of S. Athanasius, and was the less formidable of the two. His antagonist was,
by his own greater definiteness of statement, placed at a disadvantage: the consequences
which S. Athanasius had to extract from the Arian statements were by Eunomius and the
Anomœans either openly asserted or tacitly admitted: and it was thus an easier matter for
S. Gregory to show the real tendency of Anomœan doctrine than it had been for S. Athanas-
ius to point out the real tendency of the earlier Arianism. Further, it may be said that by the
time of S. Basil, still more by the time when S. Gregory succeeded to his brother’s place in
the controversy, the victory over Arianism was assured. It was not possible for S. Athanasius,
even had it been in his nature to do so, to treat the earlier Arianism with the same sort of
contemptuous criticism with which Eunomius is frequently met by S. Gregory. For S.
Gregory, on the other hand, it was not necessary to refrain from such criticism lest he should
thereby detract from the force of his protest against error. The crisis in his day was not one
which demanded the same sustained effort for which the contest called in the days of S.
29
Athanasius. Now and then, certainly, S. Gregory also rises to a white heat of indignation
against his adversary: but it is hardly too much to say that his work appears to lack just those
qualities which seem, in the writings of S. Athanasius, to have been called forth by the author’s
sense of the weight of the force opposed to him, and of the “life and death” character of the
contest. S. Gregory does not under-estimate the momentous nature of the questions at issue:
but when he wrote, he might feel that to those questions the answer of Christendom had
been already given, that the conflict was already won, and that any attempt at developing
the Arian doctrine on Anomœan lines was the adoption of an untenable position,—even
of a position manifestly and evidently untenable: the doctrine had but to be stated in clear
49
His Teaching on the Holy Trinity.