135
Book III.
§1. This third book shows a third fall of Eunomius, as refuting himself, and sometimes
saying that the Son is to be called Only-begotten in virtue of natural generation, and that Holy
Scripture proves this from the first; at other times, that by reason of His being created He
should not be called a Son, but a “product,” or “creature.”
If, when a man “strives lawfully521,” he finds a limit to his struggle in the contest by his
adversary’s either refusing the struggle, and withdrawing of his own accord in favour of his
conqueror from his effort for victory, or being thrown according to the rules of wrestling
in three falls (whereby the glory of the crown is bestowed with all the splendour of proclam-
ation upon him who has proved victorious in the umpire’s judgment), then, since Eunomius,
though he has been already twice thrown in our previous arguments, does not consent that
truth should hold the tokens of her victory over falsehood, but yet a third time raises the
dust against godly doctrine in his accustomed arena of falsehood with his composition,
strengthening himself for his struggle on the side of deceit, our statement of truth must also
be now called forth to put his falsehood to rout, placing its hopes in Him Who is the Giver
and the Judge of victory, and at the same time deriving strength from the very unfairness
of the adversaries’ tricks of wrestling. For we are not ashamed to confess that we have pre-
pared for our contest no weapon of argument sharpened by rhetoric, that we can bring
forward to aid us in the fight with those arrayed against us, no cleverness or sharpness of
dialectic, such as with inexperienced judges lays even on truth the suspicion of falsehood.
One strength our reasoning against falsehood has—first the very Word Himself, Who is the
might of our word,522 and in the next place the rottenness of the arguments set against us,
which is overthrown and falls by its own spontaneous action. Now in order that it may be
made as clear as possible to all men, that the very efforts of Eunomius serve as means for
his own overthrow to those who contend with him, I will set forth to my readers his phantom
doctrine (for so I think that doctrine may be called which is quite outside the truth), and I
would have you all, who are present at our struggle, and watch the encounter now taking
place between my doctrine and that which is matched with it, to be just judges of the lawful
striving of our arguments, that by your just award the reasoning of godliness may be pro-
claimed as victor to the whole theatre of the Church, having won undisputed victory over
ungodliness, and being decorated, in virtue of the three falls of its enemy, with the unfading
crown of them that are saved. Now this statement is set forth against the truth by way of
preface to his third discourse, and this is the fashion of it:—“Preserving,” he says, “natural
order, and abiding by those things which are known to us from above, we do not refuse to
speak of the Son, seeing He is begotten, even by the name of ‘product of generation523,’
521 2 Tim. ii. 5.
522 The earlier editions here omit a long passage, which Oehler restores.
523 γέννημα.
Book IIIThis third book shows a third fall of Eunomius, as refuting himself, and sometimes saying that the Son is to be called Only-begotten in virtue of natural generation, and that Holy Scripture proves this from the first; at other times, that by reason of His being created He should not be called a Son, but a “product,” or “creature.”
260
Book III