᾽Εγκρατεῖς, a word meaning “temperate” or
“continent.” These Encratites were heretics who abstained
from flesh, from wine, and from marriage, not temporarily but
permanently, and because of a belief in the essential impurity of those
things. They are mentioned also by Hippolytus (Phil. VIII. 13),
who calls them ἐγκρατῖται; by Clement of Alexandria (Pæd. II. 2,
Strom. I. 15, &c.), who calls them ἐγκρατηταί; by Epiphanius (Hær. 47), who agrees with
Hippolytus in the form of the name, and by others. The Encratites whom
Irenæus describes seem to have constituted a distinct sect,
anti-Jewish and Gnostic in its character. As described by Hippolytus
they appear to have been mainly orthodox in doctrine but heretical in
their manner of life, and we may perhaps gather the same thing from
Clement’s references to them. It is evident, therefore, that
Irenæus and the others are not referring to the same men. So
Theodoret, Hær. Fab. I. 21, speaks of the Severian
Encratites; but the Severians, as we learn from this chapter of
Eusebius and from Epiphanius (Hær. XLV.), were Ebionitic
and anti-Pauline in their tendencies—the exact opposites,
therefore, of the Encratites referred to by Irenæus. That there
was a distinct sect of Encratites of the character described by
Irenæus cannot be denied, but we must certainly conclude that the
word was used very commonly in a wider sense to denote men of various
schools who taught excessive and heretical abstinence. Of course the
later writers may have supposed that they all belonged to one compact
sect, but it is certain that they did not. As to the particular sect
which Irenæus describes, the statement made by Eusebius at the
close of the preceding chapter is incorrect, if we are to accept
Irenæus’ account. For the passage quoted in this chapter
states that they sprung from Marcion and Saturninus, evidently implying
that they were not founded by Tatian, but that he found them already in
existence when he became heretical. It is not surprising, however that
his name should become connected with them as their founder—for
he was the best-known man among them. That the Encratites as such
(whether a single sect or a general tendency) should be opposed by the
Fathers, even by those of ascetic tendencies, was natural. It was not
always easy to distinguish between orthodox and heretical asceticism,
and yet there was felt to be a difference. The fundamental distinction
was held by the Church—whenever it came to self-consciousness on
the subject—to lie in the fact that the heretics pronounced the
things from which they abstained essentially evil in themselves, thus
holding a radical dualism, while the orthodox abstained only as a
matter of discipline. The distinction, it is true, was not always
preserved, but it was this essentially dualistic principle of the
Encratites which the early Fathers combated; it is noticeable, however,
that they do not expend as much vigor in combating it as in refuting
errors in doctrine. In fact, they seem themselves to have been somewhat
in doubt as to the proper attitude to take toward these extreme
ascetics.