The only argument which is advanced in this note which
is different from those of other opponents of the Council, is that it
had not the authentication of a subsequent Ecumenical Synod. The
argument seems to me so extraordinary that I think Dr. Neale’s
exact words should be cited: “In the first place, we may
remark that the Second Council of Nicæa wants one mark of
authority, shared according to the more general belief by the
six—according to the opinions which an English Churchman must
necessarily embrace by the first five Councils—its recognition as Ecumenical by a
later Council undoubtedly so.” But surely this involves an
absurdity, for if it is not known whether the last one is ecumenical or
no, how will its approval of the next to the last give that council any
certainty? If III. Constantinople is doubtful being the sixth,
because there is no seventh to have confirmed it; then II.
Constantinople, the fifth, is doubtful because it has only been
confirmed by a synod itself doubtful and so on, which is absurd.
The test of the ecumenicity of a council is not its acceptance by a
subsequent synod, but its acceptance by the whole Church, and this Dr.
Neale frankly confesses is the case with regard to II. Nice:
“It cannot be denied,” he admits, “that at the
present day both the Eastern and the Latin Churches receive it as
Ecumenical” (p. 132). He might have added, “and have
done so without any controversy on the subject for nearly a thousand
years.”