schism and its overthrow, to show that those schismatics were not rebaptized at their return.
That history Augustin considers a divinely appointed refutation of all the Donatist tenets.
He proceeds to criticise their Scripture proofs, Prov. ix. 18, Jer. xv. 18, Eccl. xxxiv. 30, Ps.
cxli. 5, which he turns against them through the story of the schism. He next addresses
himself to their theory of fellowship, and discusses their proof texts, I Tim. v. 22, Is. lii. 11,
I Cor. v. 6; Ezekiel, Daniel, the Apostles, Christ and Paul all rebuke this purism. Cyprian’s
authority for rebaptism is reviewed. Augustin repeats the doubts of very many as to the
authenticity of those parts of his works which favor this view; but granted that they are valid,
Cyprian, nevertheless, maintained unity and toleration, and by martyrdom purged his
mistake. There is, however, no martyrdom outside of the unity, as that father also testified.
Cyprian acknowledged as well the presence of many evil persons in the ministry and in the
Church, but stood to it that unity must not be sacrificed on that account. The Church is a
mixed society; this is Christ’s law. Had Macrobius’s associates remembered the parable of
the wheat and tares they would not have separated. This argument is concluded with a sort
of summary of the points traversed before. As to the note of persecution: that alone is a
martyrdom which surrenders the life for a good cause. The Donatists too used the State in
the case of the Maximianists, and to them belong the Circumcelliones. The matter of unity
and the connected points of toleration and fellowship are again enlarged upon.
A sermon attributed to Augustin, De Rusticiano subdiacono a Donatistis rebaptizato et
in diaconum ordinato, falls in the same year, 409, with the letter to Bishop Macrobius. There
is an outburst of deep grief over the act. It would appear that Rusticianus had been a special
favorite of Augustin, on whom he had expended much care; but he had become involved
in scurrilous deeds, in feasting and intemperance, day and night, and was plunged in debt,
and at last was excommunicated by his presbyter, and so fled to the Donatists, by whom he
was rebaptized and made a deacon; this defection happened in the diocese of the bishop
Valerius (?); so Augustin interposed through Maximius and Theodorus with Bishop Mac-
robius, but in vain. He deplores the disgrace done to the sacrament, as dishonor done to
the sign of the King. The repetition is contradicted by the procedure with regard to the re-
turning Maximianists. He corrects the misinterpretation of Ecclus. xxxiv. 30. He wishes
for the Donatists the experience of the prodigal, that they may be forgiven by return to the
Church and so attain to the profit of charity.
Great calamities were befalling the Church in all parts of the world. Victorianus, a
presbyter, wrote to Augustin for relief from doubts as to the office of such afflictions; in the
392
bishop’s reply, [Ep. cxi.] possibly of Nov., 409, he mentions the cruelties of the Donatists at
Hippo exceeding those of the Barbarians, especially in the resort to acidified lime, clubbing,
robberies, and other destructive measures to compel rebaptism; forty-eight in one place
were thus forced to a repetition. The coercion policy, in other words, had stimulated some
of the Donatists to retaliation.
672
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.