But our discourse has diverged
too far from the subject before us, in following out the questions
which arise from time to time by way of inference. Let us therefore
once more resume its sequence, as I imagine that the phrase under
examination has been sufficiently shown, by what we have said, to be
contradictory not only to the truth, but also to itself. For if,
according to their
view, the natural relation to the Father is established by the
appellation of “the Son,” and so with that of the
“product of generation” to Him Who has begotten Him (as
these men’s wisdom falsely models the terms significant of the
Divine nature into a verbal arrangement, according to some grammatical
frivolity), no one could longer doubt that the mutual relation of the
names which is established by nature is a proof of their kindred, or
rather of their identity of essence. But let not our discourse merely
turn about our adversaries’ words, that the orthodox doctrine may
not seem to gain the victory only by the weakness of those who fight
against it, but appear to have an abundant supply of strength in
itself. Let the adverse argument, therefore, be strengthened as much as
may be by us ourselves with more energetic advocacy, that the
superiority of our force may be recognized with full confidence, as we
bring to the unerring test of truth those arguments also which our
adversaries have omitted. He who contends on behalf of our adversaries
will perhaps say that the name of “Son,” or “product
of generation,” does not by any means establish the fact of
kindred in nature. For in Scripture the term “child of wrath Cf. Eph. ii. 3” is used, and “son of perdition S. John xvii. 12.,” and “product of a viper Cf.
S. Matt. iii. 7;” and in such names surely no community
of nature is apparent. For Judas, who is called “the son of
perdition,” is not in his substance the same with perdition,
according to what we understand by the word Reading κατὰ τὸ
νοούμενον, for κατὰ τὸν
νοούμενον as the words stand in the text of Oehler, who cites no mss. in favour of the change which he has
made.. For
the signification of the “man” in Judas is one thing, and
that of “perdition” is another. And the argument may be
established equally from an opposite instance. For those who are called
in a certain sense “children of light,” and “children
of the day Cf. 1 Thess. v. 5.,” are not the same with light and
day in respect of the definition of their nature, and the stones are
made Abraham’s children Cf.
S. Matt. iii. 9 when they claim their
kindred with him by faith and works; and those who are “led by
the Spirit of God,” as the Apostle says, are called “Sons
of God Rom. viii. 14.,” without being the same with God in
respect of nature; and one may collect many such instances from the
inspired Scripture, by means of which deceit, like some image decked
with the testimonies of Scripture, masquerades in the likeness of
truth.