and our preaching is vain, and your faith is also vain," with all the rest that is appended to
it. And all these statements of the apostle are wise and good, since whatever evil they have
in them is to be imputed to those who denied the resurrection of the dead. In the same
manner also, in my epistle, take away my supposition, If every one is born again in spiritual
grace of the same character as he by whom he is baptized, and if, when the man who baptizes
is genuinely and manifestly good, he does of himself give faith, he is the origin and root and
head of him who is being born again; but when the baptizer is a wicked man, and undetected
in his wickedness, then each man who is baptized receives his faith from Christ, derives his
origin from Christ, is rooted in Christ, makes his boast in Christ as his Head:—take away,
I say, this hypothesis, on which all that follows depends, and there remains a saying of the
worst description which must fairly be ascribed to me, viz., that all who are baptized should
620
desire that they should have faithless men to baptize them, and be ignorant of their faithless-
ness. For however good men they may have to baptize them, Christ is incomparably better
who will then be the Head of the baptized, if the baptizer be a faithless man, but undetec-
ted.2418 But let the statements that you make be restored, and then it will forthwith be found
that this which depends upon it and follows in close connection from it is not my sentiment,
and that any evil which it contains is retorted on the opinion which you maintain. In like
manner, take away the supposition, If the good baptizer is the good tree, so that he whom
he has baptized is his good fruit, and if, when the character of an evil tree is concealed, then
any one that has been baptized by it is born, not of it, but of Christ,—take away this hypo-
thesis, which you were compelled to confess had its origin in your sect and in the letter of
Petilianus, and the mad conclusion which follows from it will be mine, to be ascribed to me
alone, then they are justified with greater holiness who are baptized by undetected evil men,
than they who are baptized by men that are genuinely and manifestly good.2419 But restore
the hypothesis on which this depends, and you will at once see both that I have been right
in making this statement for your correction, and that all that with good reason displeases
you in this opinion has recoiled upon your own head.
2418 See Book I. c. 6, 7.
2419 See Book I. c. 8, 9.
1235
Chapter 46