Inasmuch as he lived in, and wrote of, an age of
controversies, and his testimony must be weighed according to his
theological standpoint, this standpoint has been made the subject of
careful study. There is no doubt left by his explicit declarations
about his agreement in the main with the position of the orthodox or
catholic church of his age, as far as these are distinguished from
those of Arians, Macedonians, Eunomians, and other heretics. But as to
his attitude towards Novatianism there has been considerable difference
of opinion. That he was a member of the Novatian sect has been held
after Nicephorus Callisti
Niceph. H. E. I. 1.
by Baronius, Labbæus, and others, and argued from various
considerations drawn from his work. Some of these are: that he gives
the succession of the Novatian bishops of Constantinople;
Cf. V. 21; VII. 6, 12, 17.
that he knows and mentions Novatian bishops of other places, e.g. of
Rome,
V. 14; VII. 9, 11.
of Scythia,
VII. 46.
of Nicæa;
VII. 25.
that he mentions Novatian churches as existing in Phrygia and
Paphlagonia,
IV. 28.
in Lydia,
VI. 19.
in Cyzicum,
II. 38; III. 11.
in Nicæa,
VII. 12.
in Nicomedia and Cotyæum,
IV. 28.
and in Alexandria;
VII. 7.
that he knows and describes their church edifices;
II. 38; VII. 39.
that he knows their internal troubles and trials,
V. 21.
especially their position on the Paschal controversy;
V. 22.
that he gives vent to expressions of a sympathetic nature with the
rigor practiced by the Novatian church;
IV. 28; V. 19; VI. 21, 22; VII. 25.
that he records the criticisms of Novatians on Chrysostom and the
opinion that his deposition was a just retribution for his persecution
of the Novatians;
VI. 19 and 21.
that he attributes miracles to Paul, Novatian bishop of
Constantinople,
VII. 17, 39.
takes the testimony of Novatian witnesses,
I. 10, 13; II. 38; IV. 28.
rejects current charges against them,
V. 10.
and finally speaks of the death of Novatian as a martyrdom.
IV. 28.