He thinks, too, that the moderate and discriminating form of the correction employed, helps
to justify a resort thereto. If the Rogatists have nothing to do with the violence of the Cir-
cumcelliones, and use no force as the rest of the Donatists do, it is because they are so few
and feeble. The Donatists, however, did use the secular arm against the Maximianists, and
in the appeal to Julian. He will not allow a distinction between resort to law for the recovery
of property and for the coercion of the conscience. He claims that to regain one’s own in
this way has no apostolic warrant. The Donatists, too, sought imperial aid to coerce Cæcili-
anus. Why shall not Catholics return in kind? The very edict of confiscation which had hit
them they had hoped might fall on the head of Cæcilian and his followers. What Tychonius
said describes the very essence of Donatist arbitrariness: quod volumus sanctum est. The
sin of separation from the whole world followed; the universal church was condemned un-
heard, and the toleration which Cyprian urged disregarded. He traces his own change of
views from the non-coercive to the coercive policy, the success of the method in hastening
conversions won him wholly as an enthusiastic and persistent supporter. He bids Vincen-
tius flee from the wrath to come. What is his little handful compared with the universal
Church? This note of universality he develops in extenso against their limitation, and espe-
cially their new definition of Catholic, as obedience to all the laws and the sacraments, and
to their childish allegory of Cant. i. 7. He hints that in the ancient times there might have
been a little schism which anticipated the Rogatists, and which had called itself exclusively
the Church. He thinks it is also the duty of the State to suppress idolatry. The passage
quoted from Hilary by Vincentius, as to the few who in Asia in his day were believers in
spite of the spread of the Church, Augustin softens into an excited picture of the dark times
of persecution. Next, he discusses the position of Cyprian. All patristic testimony, however,
is of no final value; the only authority is the Word of God. Moreover, if Cyprian be quoted,
why not on the side of his love for unity and toleration? The averment that the Church,
with the exception of the Rogatists, perished by fellowship with the unbaptized, is met with
the fact that in Cyprian’s time men had been received without rebaptism into the Church,
and therefore the Church, according to their theory, must have perished before their day;
if it, however, survived that condition, then there is no excuse left for a schism on that
ground. One is not of higher merit than Cyprian simply because he may abhor that father’s
error, any more than they who did not fall into Peter’s mistake are above him in worth on
that account. Indeed Cyprian may have rectified his fault before death; and some say that
those passages are interpolations. Augustin, however, concedes their authenticity. Cyprian,
in his Epistle to Antonianus, shows how the African bishops maintained unity in spite of
the corrupt lives of some colleagues; variations of opinion were allowed; neither were they
contaminated by such a fellowship, nor was the Church destroyed. Tychonius states the
result of a Donatist council which granted fellowship to those in their own body who had
been guilty of tradition, and that without rebaptism, in case the restored should oppose such
668
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.